Submit or Track your Manuscript LOG-IN

Effect of Intra-Guild Predation and Sub Lethal Concentrations of Insecticides on the Predation of Coccinellids




Effect of Intra-Guild Predation and Sub Lethal Concentrations of Insecticides on the Predation of Coccinellids

Rahat Afza, Muhammad Afzal, Muhammad Zeeshan Majeed and Muhammad Asam Riaz*

Department of Entomology, College of Agriculture, University of Sargodha, Sargodha


Coccinellids beetles are considered one of the potential predators of the canola and mustard aphids. But the application of insecticides in field to manage aphids cause impairment of several key biological traits of the exposed coccinellids through physiological and behavioral effects. It is crucial to understand the effects of insecticides on the coccinellids. The current research was aimed at determining the intra-guild predation (IGP) of different life stages combinations of Coccinella septempunctata and Coccinella transversalis in the presence and absence of prey and the impact of sublethal concentrations of insecticides on intra-guild predation (IGP) and aphid consumption by coccinellids. Data revealed that in the absence of prey larvae of C. septempunctata exhibited more predation on C. transversalis while the predation of C. septempunctata on C. transversalis was relatively less in the presence of prey. The larvae of C. septempunctata were found stronger and competitive than larvae and adults of C. transversalis during IGP. Higher IGP of C. septempunctata on C. transversalis was linked to its larger body size. Moreover, sublethal concentrations of insecticides (lambda-cyhalothrin, cypermethrin, thiamethoxam, imidacloprid, profenophos and chlorpyriphos) significantly affected the IGP of coccinellids beetles and their aphid consumption. The effect of insecticides was concentration dependent. None of the tested insecticides was found completely harmless to coccinellids. Imidacloprid was found relatively safe to coccinellids and hence, recommended for use in canola field. It is concluded that C. septempunctata is a stronger predator showing high value of IGP and the presence of prey affects the predation of C. septempunctata on C. transversalis. Sublethal concentrations of all test insecticides exert a negative impact on IGP and aphid consumption by both these coccinellids species. Imidacloprid is relatively safe for aphid control.

Article Information

Received 12 June 2018

Revised 30 July 2018

Accepted 04 September 2018

Available online 21 February 2019

Authors’ Contribution

MAR conceived and designed the experimental protocols. RA performed the experiment. RA and MAR prepared the manuscript and analyzed the data. MA and MZM provided assistance in experimentation and manuscript preparation

Key words

Insecticides, Sublethal doses, Coccinellids, Intraguild predation, Aphids, Coccinella septempunctata, C. transversalis.


* Corresponding author:

0030-9923/2019/0002-0611 $ 9.00/0

Copyright 2019 Zoological Society of Pakistan


Beneficial arthropods play a vital role in regulating many insect pest species in agro-ecosystem. Coccinellidae family (Order: Coleoptera) is one of the main group. Their larvae and adults are known to feed voraciously on phytophagous arthropod pests including aphids (Weber and Lundgren, 2009; Ahmed et al., 2017; Arshad et al., 2018).

Although pesticides play a major role in integrated pest management (IPM) in different cropping pattern, but they are toxic to many predators and parasitoids and the evaluation of pesticide safety to biocontrol agents is usually assessed on acute toxicity basis. Recently, many scientists have paid attention on the sublethal effects of pesticides on natural enemies of insects including their adverse impact on fecundity, behavior, development rate and longevity (Croft, 1990; Desneux et al., 2004, 2007; Biondi et al., 2012; Delpuech et al., 2012; Pekar, 2012; Martinou et al., 2013).

Coccinellids are highly vulnerable to chemical insecticides which are sprayed on crops to control sucking insect pests. Generally, the 1st and 2nd instar of ladybird beetles are very sensitive to insecticides in field while these chemicals are very effective against aphids (Youn et al., 2003). Some of the insecticides kill all life stages of coccinellids that feed on the treated aphids. Theiling and Croft (1988) showed that coccinellids susceptibility to pesticides differ with the species and type of insecticide and determined that the sensitivity of coccinellid beetles to pesticides was somewhat lesser than that of pests. Insecticides usually affect the physiology and behavior of coccinellids directly (Galvan et al., 2005; Desneux et al., 2007) and reduced the prey consumption of predators (Provost et al., 2005).

In addition to above mentioned effects, the Coccinellids can, under certain conditions due to application of insecticides, engage in competitive interactions (intraguild predation) between members of the same trophic level (Provost et al., 2003; Rondoni et al., 2014). Interactions among predators are common and may generate complex effects on ecosystem dynamics. Intraguild predation is an interspecific interaction between predators sharing a common resource and the outcome is the death and consumption of one of the predators. When intraguild predation is observed in an ecosystem, the population dynamics may be modified in different ways, which in turn may cause environmental instability (Holt and Polis, 1997). Intraguild predation can affect both predator and prey populations, and consequently disrupt the biological control programs (Rosenheim et al., 1995).

Most of the previous studies have been focused on direct toxicity and mortality of coccinellids due to insecticides. However, the effect of sublethal doses of insecticides on intraguild predation has not been studied in detail. In current study, firstly we evaluated the intraguild predation (IGP) in the presence and absence of extraguild prey (aphids) among C. septempunctata and C. transversalis. Secondly, the effect of sublethal concentrations of insecticides on IGP of two coccinellids which are common predator of aphids on canola crop in Pakistan was studied under the laboratory conditions.


Table I.- Sublethal concentrations of insecticides against C. septempunctata and C. transversalis.

Names of


C. septempunctata

C. transversalis

LC10­ ­(ppm)


LC10­ ­(ppm)

LC30 (ppm)
































Materials and methods

Coccinellids (C. septempunctata and C. transversalis) were collected from canola fields which have never been exposed to insecticides, and reared in insect cages under appropriate temperature and relative humidity (26 ± 1°C, 65 ± 5% R.H) to get the homogeneous stages of above mentioned predators. Collected adults and larvae were fed on natural diet i.e. aphids. Aphid infested twigs were offered to adult and larval predators and provided with water soaked cotton.

Field survey was conducted in brassica growing region and one hundred farmers were questioned about the insecticides sprayed for the control of aphids. Survey results demonstrated six insecticides such as imidacloprid, thiamethoxam, cypermethrin, lambda-cyhalothrin, profenophos and chlorpyriphos, were sprayed against brassica aphids, hence, used in our study. LC10 and LC30 of above mentioned six formulated insecticides to C. septempunctata and C. transversalis was determined by making four serial dilutions of insecticides resulting 10 to 90% mortality. Adult beetles were treated with four concentrations of each insecticide using topical method of application (Paramasivam and Selvi, 2017). One microlitre of each concentration was applied on the dorsal side of abdomen of beetle using micropipette. Adults were kept on ice for 5min to prevent their movement before application. A total of 20 insects with three replications were released in the petri dishes to check the toxicity of each insecticide. Sufficient aphids were added in each petri dish to avoid death of beetle due to starvation. The data of mortality was recorded after 24h of treatments. LC10 and LC30 were calculated for each insecticide using Probit analysis by running Polo Plus® software (Finney, 1971).

Characterization of intraguild predation in two coccinellid beetles

Evaluation of intraguild prey was done in the presence and absence of extraguild prey (aphids). Experiments were conducted on small canola leaves which were placed on a thin layer of agar in a petri-dish to avoid leaf desiccation. Predators were starved for 24 h before test. The level of intraguild predation was determined for two predator (C. septempunctata and C. transversalis) combinations. Only mobile stages of each species for combinations of one individual were selected. The combination of egg and pupal life stages were excluded. The following combinations or treatments were selected for IGP with and without prey (Table II).


Table II.- Combinations or treatments selected for IGP with and without prey.


C. septempunctata

C. transversalis














An individual of each predator species of the selected combination was introduced on separated leaves. In the presence of extraguild prey, twenty aphids were released in petri dish followed by sealing with transparent plastic film. After 4 h, predator and prey mortality was assessed. The control treatment was consisted of only aphids to evaluate the potential of escape and the natural mortality of the aphids was also included. Fifteen replicates were set for each treatment. The corrected mortality, attributed to predator interaction, was calculated according to Soares (2002).

Where; P is the number of replicates with predation (intraguild predation), t is total number of replicates, a is number of replicates where the individual was alive and ra is the ratio of alive individuals in the control.

An index of symmetry (SI: corrected mortality in which a given predator was eaten over the total number of replicates in which there was intraguild predation) was calculated for each pair of predators and it was compared with a theoretical index of 50% (corresponding to a symmetric interaction) using a test of conformity. For each predatory pair, the level of intraguild predation (IGP: corrected mortality over the total number of replicates) was calculated.


Table III.- Combinations or treatments selected for the evaluation of predation efficacy of coccnellids.

Treatments/ combination

C. septempunctata

C. transversalis


























Impact of sublethal concentration of insecticides on intraguild predation and predation efficacy

The predation efficacy, corresponding to the number of prey consumed and mortality of coccinellid larvae and aphids was evaluated for both species of coccinellids separately and in combination to evaluate the impact of IGP. To this end, small canola leaves were treated with two sublethal concentrations (LC10 and LC30) of insecticides and were placed on a thin layer of agar in a petri-dish to avoid leaf desiccation. Predators were starved for 24 h before test. Predation efficacy was evaluated for all treatments/combinations (Table III) with a method as mentioned earlier.

There were five replicates for each treatment along with control treatment in which potential of escape and natural mortality was evaluated.


Results and discussion

Sublethal concentrations of insecticides

Results of bioassays of C. septempunctata exhibited that the sublethal concentration LC10 of profenophos, chlorpyriphos, imidacloprid, thiamethoxam, lambda cyhalothrin and cypermethrin was 3.8, 4, 88, 41, 11 and 67µL/L, respectively and LC30 of all earlier mentioned insecticides was 54, 70, 194, 135, 101 and 271 µL/L, respectively. The bioassays of C. transversalis against insecticides showed that the sublethal concentration LC10 of imidacloprid, thiamethoxam, profenophos, chlorpyriphos, lambda cyhalothrin and cypermethrin was 17, 10, 4.8, 7.9, 13 and 29µL/L, respectively and LC30 of above mentioned insecticides was 158, 117, 56, 75, 95 and 210µL/L, respectively (Table I). It is likely that both species of coccinella showed similar response to chemical insecticides. Overall, on the basis of lethal concentration, it was concluded that organophosphates revealed high toxicity to C. septempunctata and C. transversalis and compared to neonicotinoids and pyrethroids.

Among the insecticides, cypermethrin and imidacloprid exhibited lower toxicity to C. septempunctata and C. transversalis, hence considered relatively safe.

Intraguild predation in the absence/presence of prey

In the absence and presence of prey (aphids), the intraguild predation between C. septempunctata and C. transversalis was observed (Fig. 1). Intraguild predation can happen between aphidophagous predators therefore dropping their efficiency in regulating the crop pests. Between ladybirds, C. septempunctata L. and C. transversalis are the best operative predators upon aphids, the economically significant pest of canola (Rondini et al., 2014). In the absence of extraguild preys, there was more intraguild predation in most of the combination of life stages of both predators compared to presence of extraguild preys (Lucas et al., 1998). Previously, intraguild predation has also been observed in C. septempunctata and other coccinellids (Yang et al., 2017), however, IGP between C. septempunctata and C. transversalis is not well studied.

In the absence of prey (aphids) (Fig. 1A), the larvae of C. septempunctata showed more predation on C. transversalis larvae and adults as compared with the presence of prey (Fig. 1B). The adult of C. septempunctata have same level of predation on C. transversalis larvae and adults in the presence and absence of prey. The larvae and adult of C. transversalis also exhibited very low predation on larvae and adult of C. septempunctata respectively. It is likely that the larvae of C. septempunctata are good survivors in the presence and absence of prey. In the absence of prey, they start feeding on other coccinellids species or alternative to their prey for their survival which is a very useful characteristic of a good predator. Overall, C. septempunctata was superior to C. transversalis. This might be due to size of larvae and adults.


C. septempunctata were bigger than C. transversalis. Our results are in agreement with other scientists (Sengonca and Frings, 1985; Rosenheim et al., 1995; Cottrell and Yeargan, 1998; Lucas et al., 1998; Phoofolo and Obrycki, 1998; Felix and Soares, 2004).

Impact of insecticides on the intraguild predation and predation efficacy

Predation efficacy of C. septempunctata and C. transversalis larval and adult life stage alone and in combination was significantly affected by sublethal concentrations of all insecticides (Fig. 2A-F). In the absence of insecticides, the predation efficacy was significantly higher in control of all treatments. Larvae and adults of C. septempunctata exhibited higher predation efficacy as compared to C. transversalis. In all treatments, the predation efficacy was concentration dependent. The LC30 of all insecticides exhibited significantly less predation efficacy as compared to LC10 and control. Overall, the combination of larval and adult life stages of C. septempunctata and C. transversalis (T7 and T8) exhibited significantly higher predation efficacy as compared to life stages alone. But these treatments were not significantly different from each other under different insecticidal concentrations (Fig. 2A-F).

Predation efficacy of C. septempunctata and C. transversalis in different combinations/treatments was significantly affected by insecticides applied at two sublethal concentrations (LC10 and LC30). Application of all insecticides (imidacloprid, thiamethoxam, profenophos, chlorpyriphos, lambda-cyhalothrin and cypermethrin) significantly decreased the aphid consumption compared to untreated/control treatment (Fig. 2A-F). Among sublethal concentrations of all insecticides, significantly more aphids were consumed which were treated with LC10 compared to LC30. None of the combinations was considered best for predation. Overall, aphid consumption was high in combinations (from T5 to T8) as compared to the larvae and adults alone (from T1 to T4) (Fig. 2A-F). Profenophos, chlorpyriphos and cypermethrin significantly reduced the aphid consumption to 50% of coccinellids in all treatments (Fig. 2C, D, F), while imidacloprid, thiamethoxam and lambda-cyhalothrin (Fig. 2A, B, E) exhibited relatively higher aphid consumption but remained significantly lower than control. Previous studies showed that application of insecticides may cause knockdown or repellent effect on predators due to which preying efficiency can be reduced (Croft, 1990). Application of insecticides can also hyper-activate the predator as reported in Coleomegilla maculata after application of malathion which caused reduction in prey consumption (Roger et al., 1995). There may be following three reasons which caused reduction in the consumption of aphids by coccinellids beetles. First, the insecticides having repellent properties such as lambda-cyhalothrin may also increase the mobility of predator which do not feed on preys and search for untreated area (Croft, 1990). Second, after application of insecticides, the prey become


more mobile than predator that in turn must be more efficient to attack preys. Third, insecticide treated preys may be rejected by the beetles (Provost et al., 2003). Our results are in agreement with Provost et al. (2003, 2005). Although, these laboratory studies are more accurate and specific compared to semi-field and field conditions, but these studies lack the complexity of natural ecosystem and underestimate the effect of pesticides on coccinellids. Therefore further studies are required under field conditions in order to better comprehend the impact of sublethal concentrations of insecticides on intraguild predation and predatory efficacy of predatory coccinellids.



It is concluded that none of the tested insecticides was completely safe for coccinellids, however, the neonicotinoid, imidacloprid appeared relatively safer because it did not affect the aphid consumption by coccinellids and hence is recommended for aphid control in canola crop.


Statement of conflict of interest

The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests regarding the submission and publication of this work.



Ahmed, K.S., Majeed, M.Z., Rafi, M.A., Sellami, F. and Afzal, M., 2017. Biodiversity and species distribution of coccinellids (Coccinellidae: Coleoptera) in district Sargodha (Punjab), Pakistan. Pakistan J. Zool., 49: 1749-1759.

Arshad, M., Ahmad, S., Sufyan, M., Abdin, Z.U. and Maqsood, S., 2018. Population dynamics of aphids and their natural enemies associated with strip-intercropping in wheat crop. Pakistan J. Zool., 50: 1225-1230.

Biondi, A., Mommaerts, V., Smagghe, G., Viñuela, E., Zappalà, L. and Desneux, N., 2012. The non-target impact of spinosyns on beneficial arthropods. Pest Manage. Sci., 68: 1523-1536.

Cottrell, T.E. and Yeargan, K.V., 1998. Intraguild predation between an introduced lady beetle, Harmonia axyridis (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae), and a native lady beetle, Coleomegilla maculata (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae). J. Kans. entomol. Soc., 71: 159-163.

Croft, B.A., 1990. Arthropod biological control agents and pesticides. Wiley and Sons, NewYork, pp. 123.

Delpuech, J.M., Dupont, C. and Allemand, R., 2012. Effects of deltamethrin on the specific discrimination of sex pheromones in two sympatric Trichogramma species. Ecotoxicol. environ. Safe., 84: 32-38.

Desneux, N., Decourtye, A. and Delpuech, J., 2007. The sublethal effects of pesticides on beneficial arthropods. Annu. Rev. Ent., 52: 81-106.

Desneux, N., Wajnberg, E., Fauvergue, X., Privet, S. and Kaiser, L., 2004. Sublethal effects of a neurotoxic insecticide on the oviposition behavior and the patch-time allocation in two aphid parasitoids, Diaeretiella rapae and Aphidius matricariae. Ent. Exp. Appl., 112: 227-235.

Felix, S. and Soares, A.O., 2004. Intraguild predation between the aphidophagous ladybird beetles Harmonia axyridis and Coccinella undecimpunctata (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae): The role of body weight. Eur. J. Ent., 101: 237-242.

Finney, D.J., 1971. Probit analysis, 3rd edition. J. Pharm. Sci., 60: 1432-1432

Galvan, T.L., Koch, R.L. and Hutchison, W.D., 2005. Effects of spinosad and indoxacarb on survival, development and reproduction of the multicolored Asian lady beetle (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae). Biol. Contr., 34: 108-114.

Holt, R.D. and Polis, G.A., 1997. A theoretical framework for intraguild predation. Am. Natural., 149: 745-764.

Lucas, É., Coderre, D. and Brodeur, J., 1998. Intraguild predation among aphid predators: Characterization and influence of extraguild prey density. Ecology, 79: 1084-1092.[1084:IPAAPC]2.0.CO;2

Martinou, A.F., Seraphides, N. and Stavrinides, M.C., 2013. Lethal and behavioral effects of pesticides on the insect predator Macrolophus pygmaeus. Chemosphere, 96: 167-173. Paramasivam, M., and Selvi, C., 2017. Laboratory bioassay methods to assess the insecticide toxicity against insect pests-A review. J. Ent. Zool. Stud., 5: 1441-1445.

Paramasivam, M. and Selvi, C., 2017. Laboratory bioassay methods to assess the insecticide toxicity against insect pests-A review. J. Entomol. Zool. Stud., 5: 1441-1445.

Pekár, S., 2012. Spiders (Araneae) in the pesticide world: An Eco toxicological review. Pest Manage. Sci., 68: 1438-1446.

Phoofolo, M.W. and Obrycki, J.J., 1998. Potential for intraguild predation and competition among predatory coccinellidae and chrysopidae. Ent. Exp. Appl., 89: 47-55.

Provost, C.D.C., Lucas, É. and Bostanian, N.J., 2003. Impact of lambda-cyhalothrin on intraguild predation among three mite predators. Environ. Ent., 32: 256-263.

Provost, C.D.C., Lucas, E., Chouinard, G. and Bostanian, N.J., 2005. Impact of intraguild predation and lambda-cyhalothrin on predation efficacy of three acarophagous predators. Pest Manage. Sci., 61: 532-538.

Roger, C., Vincent, C. and Coderre, D., 1995. Mortality and predation efficiency of Coleomegilla maculata lengi (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae) following application of neem extracts (Azadirachta indinica A. Juss., Meliaceae). J. appl. Ent., 119: 439-443.

Rondoni, G., Ielo, F., Ricci, C. and Conti, E., 2014. Intraguild predation responses in two aphidophagous coccinellids identify differences among juvenile stages and aphid densities. Insects, 5: 974-983.

Rosenheim, J.A., Kaya, H.K., Ehler, L.E., Marois, J.J. and Jaffee, B.A., 1995. Intraguild predation among biological-control agents: Theory and evidence. Biol. Contr., 5: 303-335.

Şengonca, Ç. and Frings, B., 1985. Interference and competitive behaviour of the aphid predators, Chrysoperla carnea and Coccinella septempunctata in the laboratory. Biol. Contr., 30: 245-251.

Soares, A.O.C.M., 2000. Importancia do polimorfismo na biologia de Harmonia axyridis Pallas. Ph.D. Thesis. Universidade dos Acores, Ponta Delgada, Portugal.

Theiling, K.M. and Croft, B., 1988. Pesticide side-effects on arthropod natural enemies: A database summary. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ., 21: 191-218.

Weber, D.C. and Lundgren, J.G., 2009. Assessing the trophic ecology of the Coccinellidae: Their roles as predators and as prey. Biol. Contr., 51: 199-214.

Yang, F., Wang, Q., Wang, D., Xu, B., Xu, J., Lu, Y. and Harwood, J.D., 2017. Intraguild predation among three common coccinellids (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae) in China: Detection using DNA-based gut-content analysis. Environ. Ent., 46: 1-10.

Youn, Y.N., Seo, M.J., Shin, J.G., Jang, C. and Yu, Y.M., 2003. Toxicity of greenhouse pesticides to multicolored Asian lady beetles, Harmonia axyridis (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae). Biol. Contr., 28: 164-170.

To share on other social networks, click on P-share. What are these?

Pakistan Journal of Zoology


Vol. 51, Iss. 3, Pages 801-1202


Click here for more

Subscribe Today

Receive free updates on new articles, opportunities and benefits

Subscribe Unsubscribe