A Comparative Study of Inhibitory Properties of Saponins (derived from Azadirachta indica) for Acetylcholinesterase of Tribolium castaneum and Apis mellifera
A Comparative Study of Inhibitory Properties of Saponins (derived from Azadirachta indica) for Acetylcholinesterase of Tribolium castaneum and Apis mellifera
Amtul Jamil Sami1,*, Sehrish Bilal1, Madeeha Khalid1, Muhammad Tahir Nazir1 and A.R. Shakoori2
1Institute of Biochemistry and Biotechnology, University of the Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan
2School of Biological Sciences, University of the Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan
The study describes the effect of saponins, isolated from a medicinal plant Azadirachta indica on the CNS enzymes of a stored grain pest, Tribolium castaneum and a socioeconomic insect, Apis mellifera. A comparative study was designed to identify the role of saponins on insect acetylcholinesterase (AChEs). The enzyme activities were tested for the effect of saponins. The AChE activity of T. castaneum was inhibited by the saponins and follows competitive inhibition kinetics. In case of A. mellifera enzyme activity was not inhibited. In vitro and in vivo inhibition was observed for T. castaneum at larval stages, in dose dependent and time dependent manner. LC50 was determined to be 0.7ppm. To investigate the different effects of saponins on A. mellifera and T. castaneum AChE, computational approach was employed. For this purpose a dissection of 3-D model of A. mellifera and T. castaneum AChE enzyme was studied which showed that change in amino acid sequence of primary structure of enzyme exists at the saponin binding site, resulting in weak interaction for A. mellifera as compared to T. castaneum enzyme protein. Computational studies inidicate that A. mellifera enzyme had a little binding affinity for saponin as compared to T. castaneum AChE. The amino acid residues of T. castaneum AChE identified at positions 259(SER), 176(SER), 173(GLY), and 502 (HIS) are involved in binding with saponin molecule to form four hydrogen bonds. Whereas in A. mellifera hydrogen bonds are formed at two positions by SER 171 and TYR104 with the saponin molecule indicating weak interaction as compared to T. castaneum Saponins derived from A. indica work as biosafe pesticides as it has no considerable effect on CNS enzymes of A. mellifera (a major plant pollinator and friendly insect) as compared to T. castaneum.
Received 12 June 2017
Revised 15 July 2017
Accepted 28 July 2017
Available online 23 March 2018
AJS designed the experimental work and analyzed the results. SB and MK helped in experimentation. TN performed the computational analysis. ARS helped in the preparation of manuscript.
T. castaneum, Apis mellifera, Acetylcholinesterase, Saponins, Pesticides, Azadirachta indica.
* Corresponding author: firstname.lastname@example.org
0030-9923/2018/0002-0725 $ 9.00/0
Copyright 2018 Zoological Society of Pakistan
The widespread use of organophosphorous (OP) compounds and carbamates as pesticides generates adverse effects on non-target organisms like honeybees. The chemicals interfere with the nerve signaling and functions of the non-targeted friendly insect. Biopesticides have been applied on various plants for insect control due to their inhibitory effects on different digestive and central nervous system enzymes including cellulases and amylases (; ; ; ; ; ; ). The toxicity of these pesticides to insects is examined by their ability to inhibit acetylcholinesterase (AChE). Neem plant has long been studied for its medicinal, insecticidal, antibacterial properties and agricultural importance (; ).
The most popular plant based biopesticides are extracted from neem that is applied on both food and cash crops. More than 50 neem based commercial biopesticides which are emulsified concentrate are sold in market. Neem is one of the 29 plants species which are used against diseases of medicinal plants and pest (; ; ). Azadirachtin, a compound isolated from Neem had shown inhibitory effects on AChE enzyme activity (). The inhibitor may bind to the enzyme AChE reversibly, irreversibly or pseudo-irreversibly. To date, two different Ace genes (ace1 and ace2) that encode AChE have been found in various insects. It was reported that the expression of ace1 gene is much greater in insects as compared to ace2 and point mutations in ace1 cause insecticide resistance and reduced sensitivity, than ace2 (). Different molecular forms of Ace were identified among insects. The deduced structure of AChE of Tribolium castaneum (Herbst) (Coleoptera: Tenebrionidae), suggests that it contains all conserved sequence motifs including a choline binding site, an acyl pocket and the catalytic triad (; ). Overall structure of the protein is ellipsoidal. There are 14 α helices surrounding 12 mixed β chains. The central position is occupied by an active site gorge ~ 20 Ǻ deep (). T. castaneum is a pest that damages major stored grains, causing economic losses worldwide. AChE enzyme of T. castaneum can be targeted for pesticide development and effectively controlling crop damage by T. castaneum (). Most of the pesticides currently in use not only destroy pests but also affect friendly insects. Due to the socio economic value of A. mellifera, studies on the toxic effect of different pesticides on the honey bee is a matter of great importance, a pivotal pollinator in natural and commercial agriculture. Honeybees contact toxicity associated with AChE inhibitors are also studied (). Kinetic properties and molecular studies are reported on two AChEs from the honey bee, Apis mellifera (). Reports on structural localization of AChE activity in the compound eye of the honey bee are also presented by .
AChE enzyme is of extreme pharmacological and economic importance as it occurs as a chief CNS enzyme in insects and pests (; ). Organophosphates (OPs) and carbamates are two major classes of inhibitors used widely for inhibiting AChE. The potential of these compounds as inhibitors of AChE is both therapeutically as well as economically important. This mechanism of AChE inhibition is used both in the field of medicine for disease targeting (Alzheimers, Parkinson’s disease, Glaucoma) and in the field of agriculture for pesticides development (; ). In the process of inhibition of AChE by various classes of compounds different mechanisms are followed. OPs have the capability of phosphorylating Serine residues on the AchE in a non-reversible way thus rendering the enzyme inactive (). Carbamates another important AChE inhibiting class are derived from carbamic acid. The structure of carbamates contain carbamate moiety along with oxygen or sulphur. Carbamtes cause carbamylation of important serine residues on the AChE molecule but in a reversible manner (; ). Thus carbamates act as reversible inhibitors of AChE. Inhibition of AChE account for anti-feedant behaviors, repellancy, larval mortality and other nervous system defects in insects and pests. Various classes of compounds have been investigated as potent inhibitors of AChE and are currently in use as therapeutic agents as well as biopesticides. A. indica derived compound classified as saponins, is a heterogenous mixture of molecules varying both in their aglycone and sugar moieties. The main aglycone (sapogenin) moiety is quillaic acid, a triterpene of predominantly 30 carbon atoms (hydrophobic). The aglycone is bound to various sugars including glucose, glucuronic acid, galactose, xylose, apiose, rhamnose etc. ().
The current research report is aimed at evaluating the potential of Neem based saponin as green pesticide, to control stored grain pests. Biochemical properties of the AChE and docking studies of saponins allowed a clear understanding of several amino acids in the overall inhibition/toxicity of the compounds on T. castaneum and A. mellifera. The inhibition and antifeedant properties of AChE in response to saponins are studied through bioassays and docking experiments. The results of this study validate the importance to consider the potential of neem derived saponins in the development of natural insecticides. This is the first study on neem based saponins and can be a stepping stone to generate potential natural biopesticides.
Materials and methods
Pest selection and rearing
Tribolium castaneum commonly known as Red flour beetle was reared in the laboratory. The cultures of T. castaneum were incubated with whole wheat flour as substrate. The cultures were maintained at 37 ± 1oC with suitable humidity level to facilitate T. castaneum growth for several months to get a healthy culture. A. mellifera insects were purchased from a local farm.
Crude extract preparation
The crude extract of T. castaneum (larvae and insects) and A. mellifera (insect stage) were prepared by homogenizing 0.15g insects in 0.1% NaHCO3 solution (10mg/ml). The homogenate was centrifuged at 3000 rpm for 5 min and the supernatant was stored at -20oC till further use.
Preparation of inhibitor
For inhibition studies, Neem derived saponins were purchased from local market in Pakistan (United chemicals, Anarkali, Lahore), which were further purified by extraction with butanol. Saponins were estimated using a standard method. Digoxin (Sigma-Aldrich) was used as a standard.
Acetylcholinesterase (AChE) activity assay
The AChE activity was measured according to the method previously described by . The reaction mixture was prepared in test tubes containing 100 µl of homogenate and 2.6 ml of 0.1M phosphate buffer (pH 8). To this reaction mixture 0.01 M of the 5: 5-dithiobis-2-nitrobenzoic acid (DTNB) and 0.075 M Acetylthiocholine (ATC) was added. The reaction mixture was incubated at 30oC for 20 min and the absorbance was read at 412 nm.
Partial purification of AChE enzyme
The Protein preparations from T. castaneum (10 mg) was applied to gel filtration column (10×1.5 cm) using Sephadex- G- 100, pre-equilibrated with 20mM phosphate buffer at pH 8, and eluted by using the same buffer at a flow rate of 1 mL/min.
Void volume was calculated to be 10 ml and excluded from the protein fractions. One ml fractions were collected and were subject to Bradford assay and enzyme activity assay.
The fractions from gel filtration indicating enzyme activity were pooled together. The pooled fractions were subjected to SDS-PAGE gel (12%) at 60 V for 5 h. The gel and running buffers contained 0.5% Triton X-100 (v/v). Afterwards the gel was subjected to coomasie staining for molecular weight determination.
The pooled fractions were concentrated after precipitating with chilled acetone at -20ºC. The protein precipitates were dissolved in buffer pH 8.5 (0.05 M Tris -HCl) and were subjected to preparative PAGE without SDS, in a cold chamber with a continuous Tris-glycine buffer system.
Zymography is an electrophoretic technique which is performed for the detection of enzyme activity. The enzyme extract was subjected to electrophoresis on Native-PAGE. After PAGE the gel was sliced horizontally into 20, 1.0 mm slices. The gel was then transferred, on the 2% substrate-agar (ATC) plates in phosphate buffer pH 8.0. The gel was overlaid and was covered with cling film wrap to prevent evaporation and was incubated at 37oC for 10 min. After 10 mins, the color reagent DTNB was poured on to the plates and the AChE activity was observed.
In vitro inhibition of AChE
To determine the inhibitory effects of saponins, the enzyme was incubated with neem derived saponins of concentrations ranging from 0.05-1ppm and 2.6ml 0.1 M phosphate buffer pH 8, for 50 min at 30oC in a set of test tubes. 100 µl of 5-dithiobis-2-nitrobenzoic acid (DTNB) and Acetylthiocholine (ATC) substrate with concentrations (ranging 700 µM) was added in already incubated test tubes. The mixtures were incubated at 30oC for 20 min. The AChE activity was measured at 412 nm using a UV-visible spectrophotometer. Similar procedure was performed without inhibitor and enzyme kinetics was determined. All experiments were performed in triplicates.
One unit of AChE activity is expressed as millimoles of AChE hydrolyzed per milligram of protein per minute.
In vivo inhibition of AChE
A mortality bioassay was set up to determine the concentration of saponins for insects and larval stage of Tribolium castaneum. The insects were exposed to different concentrations of saponins (0.05, 0.1, 0.5, 1 ppm) and mortality was observed for 48 h. The results were used for probit analysis using SPSS 16.0 software (). The mortalities were corrected using formula () and results were expressed as means with standard deviations of three replicates.
The structure for AChE of T. castaneum (accession no. EZ99262.1) and A. mellifera (accession no. BAE06051.1) were generated based on homology modelling. The sequences were submitted for modelling to Swiss Model at ExPASy (Expert Protein Analysis System) bioinformatics resource portal of the Swiss Institute of Bioinformatics (SIB), an automated homology modelling serve, where BLAST was used to search the ExPDB (Expert Protein Data Bank) database for templates. AChE from Drosophila melanogaster was used as a template, as it shares high homology with AChE of these three insect species. After completing sequence alignment and its manual refinement, the catalytic site of AChE along with active site residues were analysed by the inhibitor (α-D-glucopyranosyl-(1,3)-α-D-glucuronopyranosyl-(1,3))α-3-hydroxyolean-12-ene-28-oate, a Saponin molecule using Docking Server (; ).
Results and Discussion
Saponins were quantified using vanillin-sulfuric acid assay (). To perform the test, 0.25mL of saponin solution was mixed with 0.25mL of 10% (w/v) vanillin, dissolved in methanol, on ice-bath. 2.5 mL sulphuric acid (72% w/v) was added and mixed followed by heating at 60°C for 10 min, cooled and taken absorbance at 544 nm. Standard graph of digitalis (digoxin) was built to use as reference for estimation of saponin content.
Characteristics of AChE
The crude extract of T. castaneum (insect and larvae) was used for the total protein estimation and was determined to be 0.49 mg/ml. The rate of enzyme activity was 5.7 µmol/min/mg of protein. Gel filtration chromatography was performed for the partial purification of enzyme (AChE) (). All the fractions were tested for protein concentration and enzyme activity. Fractions showing enzymatic activity were collected and pooled together were subjected to preparative native-PAGE analysis. Following native-PAGE the gel was sliced horizontally into 1.0 mm slices, as described previously (). Each slice was tested for acetylcholinestrase activity by zymogram technique also. Results showed that Fraction No. 11, 12 and 13 had the enzyme activity as it appeared yellow on the Zymogram (), diffused activity of enzyme is visible in yellow due to higher rate of reaction. Protein was extracted from the native-PAGE and SDS-PAGE was performed to determine the molecular weight and test the immunogenic activity. The gel showed a band of 35 kDa, and immunogenic activity in an immunoblotting assay ().
AChE isolated from T. castaneum and A. mellifera were studied for the inhibition by Saponins. It was observed that AChE from T. castaneum was almost completely inhibited while there was little or no effect on Apis mellifera enzyme ().
Saponins were able to inhibit the AChE in T. castaneum in a linear fashion with the increase in the concentration of enzyme activity. The AChE is the target site of many organophosphate and carbamate insecticides in central nervous system of various insects and vertebrates. The main effects of neem and saponins in our experiments were the inhibition of AChE in higher doses of neem based saponins treatment in T. castaneum. Further the results were compared with Honey bee acetylcholinesterase and it was observed that saponins do not inhibit AChE in Apis mellifera (). The results demonstrate that saponins can be very useful botanical insecticides which exert toxic affects to target species but do not affect non-target species of insects.
Inhibition kinetics was studied using Line-weaver Burk Plot. The Km was calculated to be 0.0463 M and 0.093 M with and without inhibitor, and the Vmax was 0.839µM/min. The Vmax with and without inhibitor remain unchanged indicating that the inhibitor binds at the catalytic site of enzyme. The Ki was calculated to be 2.5 M ().
Effect of saponins on larvae
The LC25, LC50 and LC90 were calculated by probit analysis as 0.03 ppm and 0.7 ppm and 2.0 ppm respectively, P < 0.002. The concentration of saponin (isolated from Neem) equal to LC50 also inhibited AChE of T. castaneum. The inhibition of AChE at various concentrations of saponins can be seen in . The activity of AChE was inhibited considerably. The sprays made by saponin based formulations can be very useful to eradicate major pests of stored food grains such as rice, pulses and wheat products. These pests are widely distributed all around the world and cause extensive damage to stored food each year ().
The effect on AChE enzyme activity was dependent on inhibitor’s concentration. Our studies revealed that pure forms of saponins are more effective against T. castaneum, as these insects are very resilient and survive even harsh conditions. More than 70% insects died above 0.7 ppm and 1 ppm was most effective over 24 h period ().
Repellency behaviour of insects to saponins
For the determination of antifeedant behavior of insects in response to saponins live T. castaneum larvae were used. Commercially available neem seed extracts have diverse pest control properties, affecting insect growth, fertility, and metamorphosis in addition to direct toxicity and antifeedent and oviposition-deterrent effects. Recent studies indicate there are now over 500 species of insects and mites resistant to biopesticides. There are over 1,000 insect/insecticide resistance combinations, and at least 17 species of insects that are resistant to all major classes of bioinsecticides ().
The results showed that there is an impact of neem derived compounds on the repellency of insects (, ). Furthermore, the role of Neem derived compounds on the nervous system enzyme AChE was investigated.
AChE model is built at SwissModel server using homology modeling, Drosophila melanogaster AChE was used as a template for modeling showing 62.02% homology. Further, Docking calculations performed using Docking Server.
Docking showed that saponins bind in the catalytic triad of 20 Aº deep active site gorge making the enzyme unable to bind the original substrate. However, the AChE are enzymes with high substrate specificities and the potential substrates are able to fit the catalytic centre, although AChE exhibits reduced sensitivity against insecticides. A dissection of binding/interaction sites of the enzymes with the target molecule (Saponin) showed that the A. mellifera enzyme had a little binding affinity for saponin as compared to T. castaneum AChE. In T. castaneum AChE the amino acid residues identified at positions SER259 (-54.129 Kcal/mol), SER176 (-1.2678 Kcal/mol), GLY173 (1.0287 Kcal/mol), and HIS502 (10.6928 Kcal/mol) shows hydrogen bond with Saponin molecule. GLN111 (0.0921 Kcal/mol), ASN127 (0.1137 Kcal/mol) and TRP292 (3.1102 Kcal/mol) shows polar bond, hydrophobic interactions shows with amino acids LEU181 (-0.9041 Kcal/mol), TYR114 (-0.5178 Kcal/mol), LEU349 (-0.256 Kcal/mol) and PRO128 (0.6939 Kcal/mol), however surface binding studies shown that molecule is completely fit inside the AChE enzyme ().
The sequence of Apis mellifera AChE was docked with saponin molecule. The estimated free energy of binding appear to be +221.7 kcal/mol. The frequency of binding was 40%. 2D plot for the docking shows following type of interactions: SER171 and TYR 104 formed hydrogen bond with binding energies (-3.458 and 10.041), respectively while TRP116, PHE 345, PHE 386, TYR385, were involved in cation-pi interaction. Hydrophobic interaction was formed by PHR350, TYR179, TRP163 (). It is revealed from the in silico study that this complex between the enzyme and inhibitor is less stable due to high energy of the required hydrogen bonds as compared to Tribolium AChE-I saponin complex (). Summarily neem derived saponins could be used as economical and sustainable green biopesticides.
Neem derived saponins have higher affinity for insect pests by inhibiting the nervous system enzyme, Acetylcholinesterase. Saponins could be used as bio-safe green pesticides. Non interaction of A. mellifera nervous system enzyme is due to lack of binding affinity for saponins. Saponin based biopesticide treatments on plants is an economical technique that can be used to protect crops from damage and to increase biomass production.
The authors are grateful to Higher Education Commission Pakistan for financial assistance to conduct this research.
Statement of conflict of interest
The authors confirm that this article content has no conflict of interest.
Ashfaq, U.A., Jalil, A. and Qamar, M.T.U., 2016. Antiviral phytochemicals identification from Azadirachta indica leaves against HCV NS3 protease: an in silico approach. Nat. Prod. Res., 30: 1866-1869.
Darvesh, S., Darvesh, K.V., McDonald, R.,S., Mataija, D., Walsh, R., Mothana, S., Lockridge, O. and Martin, E., 2008. Carbamates with differential mechanism of inhibition toward acetylcholinesterase and butyrylcholinesterase. J. med. Chem., 51: 4200–4212.
Dulin, F., Halm-Lemeille, M.P., Lozano, S., Lepailleur, A., Sopkova-de, Oliveira, Santos, J., Rault, S. and Bureau, R., 2012. Interpretation of honeybees contact toxicity associated to acetylcholinesterase inhibitors. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Safe., 79: 13-21.
Grünwald, S., Adam, I.V., Gurmai, A.M., Bauer, L., Boll, M. and Wenzel, U., 2013. The red flour beetle Tribolium castaneum as a model to monitor food safety and functionality. Yellow biotechnology, I. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg, pp. 111-122.
Lee, S.W., Kasai, S., Komagata, O., Kobayashi, M., Agui, N., Kono, Y. and Tomita, T., 2007. Molecular characterization of two acetylcholinesterase cDNAs in Pediculus human lice. J. med. Ent., 1: 72-79.
Lu, Y., Park, Y., Gao, X., Zhang, X., Yao, J., Pang, Y.P., Jiang, H. and Zhu, K.Y., 2012. Cholinergic and non-cholinergic functions of two acetylcholinesterase genes revealed by gene-silencing in Tribolium castaneum. Scient. Rep., 2: 1-7.
Manavalan, P., Taylor, P. and Johnson, Jr. W.C., 1985. Circular dichroism studies of acetylcholine sterase conformation. Comparison of the 11 S and 5.6 S species and the differences induced by inhibitory ligands. BBA- Protein Struct. M., 829: 365-370.
Meena, J., Ojha, R., Muruganandam, A.V. and Krishnamurthy, S., 2011. Asparagus racemosus competitively inhibits in vitro the acetylcholine and monoamine metabolizing enzymes. Neurosci. Lett., 503: 6-9.
Morris, G.M., Goodsell, D.S., Halliday, R.S., Huey, R., Hart, W.E., Belew, R.K. and Olson, A.J., 1998. Automated docking using a Lamarckian genetic algorithm and an empirical binding free energy function. J. comp. Chem., 19: 1639-1662.
Sami, A.J. and Shakoori, A.R., 2007. Extracts of plant leaves have inhibitory effect on the cellulase activity of whole body extracts of insects-a possible recipe for bioinsecticides. Proc. Pak. Congr. Zool., 27: 105-118.
Sami, A.J., Bilal, S., Khalid, M., Shakoori, F.R., Rehman, F.U. and Shakoori, A.R., 2016. Effect of crude neem (Azadirachta indica) powder and azadirachtin on the growth and acetylcholinesterase activity of Tribolium castaneum (Herbst) (Coleoptera: Tenebrionidae). Pakistan J. Zool., 48: 881-886.
Zhu, K.Y., and Zhang, Z.J., 2005. Insect acetylcholinesterase and its roles in insecticide resistance. In: Entomological research: Progress and prospect (eds. T.X. Liu and G. Le) Science Press, Beijing, China, pp. 226-234.