Substitution of Fish Oil with Selected Dietary Oils: Effects on Growth Performance, Nutrient Digestibility and Body Composition of Catla catla Fingerlings

Syed Makhdoom Hussain*, Hafiza Hina Shafqat, Muhammad Faisal, Mahnoor Saleem, Zeeshan Yousaf and Muhammad Amjad

Fish Nutrition Lab, Department of Zoology, Government College University, Faisalabad, Pakistan.

ABSTRACT

A feeding trial of 70-days was conducted on Catla catla fingerlings (average weight 6.73±0.04). Total six experimental diets were formulated containing levels I (control), II, III, IV, V and VI. Diet I constituted fish oil (FO), while diets II, III, IV, V and VI were composed of palm oil, corn oil, sunflower oil, canola oil and mixture of all mentioned vegetable oils respectively. Triplicate tanks were used and every tank had 15 fingerlings. Results demonstrated that significant (p<0.05) improvement in growth performance i.e. weight gain % (WG %) (210.48), minimum feed conversion ratio (FCR) (1.11) and maximum specific growth rate (SGR) (1.61) of fingerlings were noted when fed with test diet-VI-based on plant mixture oil. When compared to a control diet (0%) and other oil based experimental diets, such results were significantly different. While minimum growth i.e. WG % (148.13), maximum FCR (1.43) and minimum SGR (1.29) was noted when fingerlings were fed with test diet-IV. In the current study, the best digestibility results of crude fat (CF) (81.25%), crude protein (CP) (69.39%), and gross energy (GE) (71.74) were seen in VI-level diet and these results were statistically (p<0.05) different from all other test diets. However, the test diet-IV had the least digestibility value of nutrients, including CF (73.55%), CP (49.17%) and GE (65.96%). It was concluded that C. catla fingerlings showed improvement in growth performance, nutrient digestibility and body composition when fed plant mixture oil based diet.

Article Information

Received 31 October 2022

Revised 28 November 2022

Accepted 15 December 2022

Available online 13 February 2023

(early access)

Published 04 April 2024

Authors’ Contribution

SMH administered and supervised the project and acquired funds. HHS and SMH wrote the manuscript. MF, MS, ZY and MA curated data and reviewed and edited the manuscript.

Key words

Dietary oils, Catla catla, Growth performance, Nutrient digestibility

DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.17582/journal.pjz/20221031171041

* Corresponding author: drmakhdoomhussain@gcuf.edu.pk

0030-9923/2024/0003-1193 $ 9.00/0

Copyright 2024 by the authors. Licensee Zoological Society of Pakistan.

This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).

INTRODUCTION

Aquaculture relies highly on nutritionally balanced feed to fulfil the needs of aquatic species (Dawood, 2021). The aquaculture industry has notably expanded due to the increasing need for sustainable and profitable animal protein sources to feed the world’s rapidly increasing population (FAO, 2020). According to predictions, world’s population will reach 9 billion people in 2050. To meet the expanded population’s need, about 50% additional food will be required (Diana et al., 2013). Increased demand for nutritional quality has resulted from rapid population increase in developing countries across the world (Abdulkadir et al., 2016). The fish nutritionists areprimarily focused at forming diet that is of high quality as well as economical. Feed cost is predicted to account for 50 to 60% of total aquaculture expenses (Shahzad et al., 2018).

Fish oil (FO) has vital lipid sources because of its important fatty acid composition (Kok et al., 2020). Main source of lipids is FO and can be added in fish diets at higher levels. FO has large amount of polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA), particularly highly-unsaturated fatty acids (HUFA) so that’s why it has been used as a primary source of lipids (Fukada et al., 2017). Furthermore, due to the high cost of these substances and the scarcity of resources, non-traditional substitutes of lipid sources are being used (Gasco et al., 2018). Plant oils are the greatest substitute for FO because of their high availability, rising production, and low cost (Turchini et al., 2009).

Lipid substances in aquaculture feeds should be healthy and accessible at reasonable levels (Alhazzaa et al., 2019). Vegetable oil (VOs) supply is becoming more consistent and costs are cheaper as compared to FO (Ayisi et al., 2019; Turchini et al., 2019). VOs are less susceptible to pollution and lipid peroxidation than FO (Larbi et al., 2018; Ayisi et al., 2019). For this approach, a variety of plant lipid resources, such as soybean, palm, sesame, linseed, olive, rapeseed, and sunflower oils, are commonly employed in the formulation of aquaculture feed (Cottrell et al., 2020). These oils increase fish growth performance and also helpful for the formulation of economical aquaculture feed.

Numerous researchers have found that substituting VOs with FO improves growth performance as in Nile tilapia (Apraku et al., 2017). At optimum temperature, the results showed that groups fed VOs based diets had significantly greater growth performance and feeding efficiency (p<0.05) than those provided FO-based diets (Dernekbasi et al., 2021). Fish that received 2% VOs based diet such as coconut oil based diet showed higher specific growth rate (SGR), feed intake, weight gain (WG) and final weight (FW) (Dawood, 2021). Growth performance and body composition were significantly improved when yellow drum fed with mixed oil based diet (Wabike et al., 2020).

C. catla is a top feeder and being reared with other carp species in Pakistan (Aslam et al., 2016). Because of its nutritional quality, high commercial value, fast growth, good taste and acclimatization to laboratory conditions, this carp species is being cultured at large scale (Milstein et al., 2002). Because of its size, excellent flavor, rich in protein content, omega-3 fatty acids, and lower triglycerides, it is the most frequently farmed freshwater fish among Indian major carps (IMCs) (Vanitha et al., 2015). This study is aimed at asses the effect of replacement of FO with various oils on growth performance, nutrient digestibility and body composition and of C. catla fingerlings. Thus, it will be economically important for feed manufacturers.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Acclimatization of fish and trial conditions

Fingerlings were bought from local fish hatchery, Satiyana road, Faisalabad, Pakistan. They were placed in V-shaped tanks with water holding capacity of 70L (specifically designed to collect feces). Fingerlings were bathed in a salt solution before beginning the feeding trial to eliminate parasites from their skin (Rowland and Ingram, 1991). Then fingerlings were acclimatized to be familiar with lab conditions for two weeks. The basal diet was fed during acclimatization period to the fingerlings for apparent satiation. All the experimental tanks were supplied with aeration by capillary system for 24 h daily.

Experimental layout

Different types of oils were used to make fish feed. FO was utilized to formulate the control diet whereas five test diets were formulated by using different vegetable oils e.g. corn oil, palm oil, canola oil, sunflower oil and one diet was prepared by mixing all of the selected oils. The feed was given to juveniles at 5% of their live wet weight every day. The trial lasted for total of 70 days.

Formulation of pellets

For the preparation of experimental diets, ingredients were bought from a commercial feed mill and tested chemically. For 10 min, all of the diet ingredients (Table I) were mixed using mixer. Different oils were added slowly to the diet while mixing the ingredients. Chromium oxide (1%) was utilized as an inert marker. Water was added at a rate of 10-15% to prepare suitable dough (Lovell, 1989). Then this dough was processed using pelleting apparatus to make feed pellets. All experimental diets were processed in the same manner in the pelleting machine to formulate six different oil based diets. The diet was completely dried in the shade and kept at 4°C until it was utilized.

Feeding protocol and sample collection

Different dietary oil based diets were given to fingerlings. Two hour after feeding practice, the tanks valves were opened and the uneaten feed was removed from each tank. For removal of feed residues, the tanks were washed thoroughly and filled with water. Fingerlings were then put back into tanks and fecal matter was collected from each tank through fecal collecting tube, once the valves were opened after a 2 h interval. Precautions were taken during collecting thin fecal fibers to reduce nutrient loss. Each treatment’s feces were dehydrated, ground, and preserved for lab testing.

Chemical analysis of feed, feces and fish muscle

Samples of diet ingredients, feces and fingerling muscles were assembled by pestle and mortar, separately. The analysis was done using standard protocols (AOAC, 2005). Assessment of moisture was done through oven drying for 12 h at 105°C and calculation of crude protein (N×6.25) was done by using micro Kjeldahl equipment. The Soxtec HT2 1045 system extracted crude fat using the petroleum ether extraction technique. Ash was heated in an electric furnace for 12 h at 650°C to create a constant weight (Eyela-TMF 3100). Gross energy calculations were done using an oxygen bomb calorimeter.

Growth studies

For assessment of growth, fish from each tank was weighed at the end and start of trial. Growth performance of juveniles in term of WG %, FCR and SGR was estimated by using these standard formulae:

Digestibility determination

The following formula was used to figure out the apparent nutrient digestibility coefficients (ADC) for the experimental diets:

Chromic oxide estimation

Following oxidation with molybdate solution, the amount of chromic oxide in the diet was measured using a UV-VIS 2001 Spectrophotometer with an absorbance setting of 370 nm (Divakaran et al., 2002).

Statistical analysis

Fingerlings nutrient digestibility, growth performance and body composition were compared using one-way ANOVA (Steel and Torrie, 1996). Tukey’s Honest Significant Difference Test was used to evaluate the differences between means, and p0.05 was assumed to be statistically significant (Snedecor and Cochran, 1991). Computer application Co-Stat was applied for statistical analysis.

RESULTS

Growth performance

Findings of growth of fingerlings given various dietary oil based diets are provided in Table II. Initial weight of fingerlings was nearly identical across all treatments, however weight of fingerlings assessed after the trial was considerably different from others. The maximum values of weight gain (14.20±0.03g), weight gain% (210.48±0.99%) of C. catla fingerlings were noted in fish fed at VI-level of different plant mixture oil based diet followed by fish (12.48±0.04g; 185.16±0.75%) fed at V-level of palm oil based diet. When compared to the control diet (11.33 0.05 g; 168.35 1.08%) and other test diets, these results were shown to be statistically (p 0.05) different. The minimum weight gain (9.99±0.08 g), weight gain % (148.13±1.99%) were recorded at IV level of canola oil based diet. FCR of fingerlings was also significantly increased. The lowest value of FCR was noted (1.11±0.02) at test diet VI while highest value of FCR was observed (1.43±0.02) at test diet IV. In case of SGR (%) results showed that the VI-level of plant mixture oil based diet had the maximum SGR value (1.61±0.004%) of fish. Minimum value of SGR (1.29±0.01%) was indicated in fish fed at the IV-level of canola oil based-diet. Overall, it was assessed that fingerlings showed improvement in growth with respect to WG, WG (%) FCR and SGR (%) at VI level of plant mixture oil based diet.

 

Table I. Ingredients composition (%) of test diets.

Ingredients	Test diet-I (Control)	Test diet-II	Test diet-III	Test diet-IV	Test diet-V	Test diet-VI
Canola meal	32	32	32	32	32	32
Fish meal	20	20	20	20	20	20
Corn gluten meal (60%)	15	15	15	15	15	15
Wheat flour	16	16	16	16	16	16
Rice polish	7	7	7	7	7	7
Fish oil	6
Canola oil		6
Sunflower oil			6
Corn oil b				6
Palm oil					6
Oil mixture						6
Vitamin premix*	1	1	1	1	1	1
Mineral premix**	1	1	1	1	1	1
Ascorbic acid	1	1	1	1	1	1
Chromic oxide	1	1	1	1	1	1

 

Table II. Growth performance of C. catla fingerlings fed different oil based diets.

Growth parameters	Test diet-I (Control diet)+ fish oil	Test diet-II+ sunflower oil	Test diet-III +corn oil	Test diet-IV+ canola oil	Test diet-V+ palm oil	Test diet-VI+ plant mixture oil
IW (g)	6.73±.02a	6.73±.01a	6.74±.03a	6.75±.04a	6.74±.01a	6.75±.03a
FW (g)	18.06±0.04c	17.95±0.04d	16.89±0.03e	16.74±0.04f	19.22±0.03b	20.95±0.04a
WG (g)	11.33±0.05c	11.22±0.03c	10.14±0.04d	9.99±0.08e	12.48±0.04b	14.20±0.03a
WG (%)	168.35±1.08c	166.67±0.35c	150.42±0.94d	148.13±1.99d	185.16±0.75b	210.48±0.99a
WG (fish/day)g	1.41±0.002c	1.40±0.001c	1.31±0.005d	1.29±0.011d	1.49±0.003b	1.61±0.004a
FCR	1.31±0.02a	1.35±0.09ab	1.42±0.02bc	1.43±0.02c	1.22±0.01a	1.11±0.02a
SGR	1.41±0.002c	1.40±0.001c	1.31±0.005d	1.29±0.011d	1.49±0.003b	1.61±0.004a

 

At p<0.05, means with various superscripts are statistically different. The data is based on three replicates. IW, initial weight; FW, final weight; WG, weight gain; FCR, feed conversion ratio.

 

Table III. Analyzed compositions of CP, CF and GE in the feed and feces, apparent nutrient digestibility of C. catla fingerlings fed different oil based diets.

Parameters	Test diet-I (Control diet)+ fish oil	Test diet-II+ sunflower oil	Test diet-III +corn oil	Test diet-IV+ canola oil	Test diet-V+ palm oil	Test diet-VI+ plant mixture oil
Analysis of feed
CP (%)	30.79±0.04a	30.82±0.10a	30.73±0.07a	30.74±0.06a	30.62±0.11a	30.58±0.03a
CF (%)	7.31±0.015a	7.27±0.01a	7.28±0.03a	7.31±0.02a	7.29±0.03a	7.30±0.03a
GE(kcalg-1)	3.44±0.01a	3.43±0.02a	3.42±0.01a	3.41±0.01a	3.45±0.02a	3.46±0.01a
Analysis of feces
CP (%)	12.24±0.45d	13.07±0.06c	14.23±0.07b	15.22±0.07a	11.28±0.05e	10.18±0.04f
CF (%)	1.79±0.035c	1.86±0.036b	1.89±0.03b	1.98±0.005a	1.70±0.01d	1.58±0.02e
GE(kcalg-1)	1.10±0.03a	1.11±0.02a	1.13±0.02a	1.13±0.01a	1.08±0.03a	1.06±0.01a
Apparent nutrient digestibility
CP (%)	60.98±1.19bc	54.38±5.52cd	53.69±1.26d	49.17±0.14d	64.78±0.20ab	69.39±0.08a
CF (%)	77.21±0.23c	75.80±1.00d	75.50±1.00d	73.55±0.14e	78.92±0.24b	81.25±0.31a
GE(kcalg-1)	68.52±1.35c	67.63±0.40d	66.96±0.28e	65.96±0.51f	70.00±0.66b	71.74±0.22a

 

At p<0.05, means with various superscripts are statistically different. The data is based on three replicates. CP, crude protein; CF, crude fat; GE, gross energy.

 

Nutrient digestibility calculation

Table III show the examined nutrient content of the diet including crude protein (CP), crude fat (CF), and gross energy (GE) and excretions of fingerlings fed on various oil based diets. In comparison to the digestibility values of the control diet and all other diets, it was found that the diet based on plant combination oil had the greatest (69.39%) and significantly different (p0.05) crude protein digestibility. The results demonstrated a dramatic increase in nutrient digestibility up to VI-level when it achieved its highest, with a mixture of various plant oils in the diet, whereas subsequent increased in plant mixture oil level resulted in lower nutritional digestibility. The digestibility findings at VI level were found to be the greatest and statistically (p0.05) different from all other test diets for CF (81.25%), CP (69.39%), and GE (71.74) (Table III). While, minimum digestibility results of nutrients such as CF (73.55%), CP (49.17%) and GE (65.96%) were obtained at diet IV. These results showed that a plant combination oil based diet gave fingerlings the best nutrient digestion and caused the least quantity of nutrients to be released into the environment.

Body composition

Results of body composition of fingerlings in term of CP, CF, ash and moisture are represented in the Table IV. The best value of CP content (20.25±0.07 %) and lowest value of fat (5.34±0.01 %) collected in the body of fingerlings were obtained when fingerlings fed with plant mixture oil based diet while minimum value of CP content

 

Table IV. Body composition of C. catla fingerlings fed with different oil based diets.

Body composition parameters	Test diet-I (Control diet)+ fish oil	Test diet-II+ sunflower oil	Test diet-III +corn oil	Test diet-IV+ canola oil	Test diet-V+ palm oil	Test diet-VI+ plant mixture oil
Protein (%)	18.68±0.17c	18.05±0.15d	17.54±0.08e	16.77±0.21f	19.33±0.10b	20.25±0.07a
Fat (%)	5.81±0.08d	5.97±0.15c	6.03±0.13b	6.15±0.15a	5.63±0.03e	5.34±0.01f
Ash (%)	3.16±0.02bcd	3.24±0.05bc	3.29±0.02b	3.47±0.02a	3.09±0.01c	3.02±0.01cd
Moisture (%)	72.35±0.19d	72.74±0.12c	73.14±0.12b	73.61±0.18a	71.95±0.11e	71.39±0.08f

 

At p<0.05, means with various superscripts are statistically different. The data is based on three replicates.

 

(16.77±0.21 %) and maximum value of CF (6.15±0.15 %) collected in the fingerlings body were observed when fingerlings fed with canola oil based diet. These values showed that there was significant difference (p<0.05) among them. Highest values of ash content (3.47±0.02 %) and moisture (73.61±0.18 %) in the fingerlings body were recorded when fingerlings fed with canola oil based diet while lowest values of ash and moisture contents (3.02±0.01% and 71.39±0.08%, respectively) in the body of fingerlings were observed when fingerlings fed with plant mixture oil based diet.

DISCUSSION

Current study found that a mixture of VOs can be used to substitute FO in the feed of fingerlings without compromising their growth, nutrient digestibility and body composition. Lipids in aqua-feeds must be safe and readily available in moderate proportions (Alhazzaa et al., 2019).

It is shown that replacement of FO with various sources of oils significantly influenced the growth performance of fingerlings. While opposed to a FO-based diet, a plant mixture oil based diet improved the growth performance of fish. Our results are similar with (Dernekbasi et al., 2021) who suggested that plant mixture oil based diets enhanced the growth performance of fish without adverse effect on environment. Shahrooz et al. (2018) also stated that fish, when fed on plant mixture oil based diet resulted highest feed intake and maximum growth rate as compare to the fish that fed on FO based diet. Similar to our results, FW, WG, SGR and PER were indicated significant improvement in yellow drum when fish fed mixed oil based diet (Wabike et al., 2020). The growth results of the current study did not match those of Mu et al. (2020), who discovered a significant decline in growth and feed intake in large yellow croaker on a diet in which plant oils completely replaced FO. In contrast to the findings of this study, Peng et al. (2016) found that juvenile Nile tilapia fed a VOs-based diet, such as soybean oil, had lower WG, PER, FCR, and SGR than fish fed a FO-based diet.

It was also indicated that highest nutrient digestibility in terms of CP, CF and GE at plant mixture oil followed by palm oil based diets. Duan et al. (2014) observed highest protein in fish that fed on partial or total replacement of FO with palm oil and plant mixture oil based diets, respectively. The findings of this study revealed that a minimum number of nutrients such as CP, CF, and apparent GE were eliminated through feces at levels containing plant mixture oil followed by palm oil. According to Larbi et al. (2018) fingerlings fed a palm oil based diet had no deleterious impacts on nutrient discharge, while a palm oil based diet had negative effects on innate immunological parameters and antioxidant activity. Findings of current research work revealed that GE digestibility was maximum at the level of plant mixture oil and that it differed considerably from results obtained in other test diets. When comparing the apparent digestibility coefficient values of control diet and different levels of plant oil based diets, the findings revealed that the plant mixture oil level offered the highest apparent digestibility coefficient value.

Body composition of fingerlings was improved when fingerlings were fed with plant mixture oil based diet. Our results also matched with the Milián-Sorribes et al. (2021) who found that vegetable mixture oil improved the protein content in Seriola dumerili. Results of Wabike et al. (2020) also similar with the current study, who found that CF, moisture and ash contents significantly higher in yellow drum when fish fed with mixed oil based diet. Also similar to our outcomes, Ayisi et al. (2019) stated that whole body protein of Nile tilapia improved when fish fed with VOs based diets. According to the findings of this study, better growth has been directly corresponded to the high content of protein for these diets used by these authors which showed that fish growth is positively affected by protein accumulation in skeletal muscles. In opposite to our findings, Erondu et al. (2021) concluded that the protein content in Nile tilapia was lowest when fish given with VOs based diet. Some results of our study were same as to Milián-Sorribes et al. (2021) who described that fat content was lowered when S. dumerili fed with vegetable mixture oil based diet. Similar to our findings Ayisi et al. (2017) also found in his study that whole body fat composition of fish was lowered. Dissimilar to current research findings, Erondu et al. (2021) concluded that fish fed with VOs based diets increased the whole body fat content of fish. The results found in this work also mismatched with the findings of (Sankian et al., 2019; El-Asely et al., 2020) who suggested that there was more improvement in the body lipids of several fish species including Nile tilapia when fishes fed with VOs based diet than FO based diet. The contradiction between these authors and current study’s results might be associated with changes in the preparation of diet, fish species, size of fish, lipid contents in the diet, and different environment as well as experimental conditions.

CONCLUSION

The ideal amount of a distinct plant combination oil based diet for increasing growth metrics, body composition and nutrient digestibility in C. catla fingerlings was identified in this study. It has also been recommended that substituting plant mixture oil for FO in the production of cost-effective and environmentally friendly aquaculture feed for C. catla fingerlings has been highly beneficial.

AKNOWLEDGEMENT

The authors are thankful to HEC Pakistan for funding Department of Zoology, Government College University, Faisalabad for provision of facilities for this research.

Funding

The funds for this project were provided by HEC, Pakistan vide Projects No. 20-4892/NRPU/RandD/HEC/14/1145 and 5649/Punjab/NRPU/RandD/HEC/2016

IRB approval

The experiment was carried out in line with the institutional review board guidlines of Government College University, Faisalabad.

Ethical statement

Ethical approval is not required for this study.

Statement of conflict of interest

The authors have declared no conflict of interest.

REFERENCES

Abdulkadir, A.R., Zawawi, D.D., and Jahan, M.S., 2016. Proximate and phytochemical screening of different parts of Moringa oleifera. Russ. Agric. Sci., 42: 34-36. https://doi.org/10.3103/S106836741601002X

Alhazzaa, R., Nichols, P.D., and Carter, C.G., 2019. Sustainable alternatives to dietary fish oil in tropical fish aquaculture. Rev. Aquacult., 11: 1195-1218. https://doi.org/10.1111/raq.12287

AOAC (Association of official analytical chemists). 2005. Official methods of analysis 18th ed. Gaithersburg, Maryland: AOAC, vol. 1, pp. 8-21.

Apraku, A., Liu, L., Leng, X., Rupia, E.J., and Ayisi, C.L., 2017. Evaluation of blended virgin coconut oil and fish oil on growth performance and resistance to Streptococcus iniae challenge of Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus). Egypt. J. Basic appl. Sci., 4: 175-184. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejbas.2017.06.002

Aslam, S., Abbas, S., Kalhoro, M.A., and Shoaib, A., 2016. Anchor worms (lernaeid parasites), Lernaea polymorpha yü and Lernaea cyprinacea (copépode: lernaeidae) on major carps at different fish farms in Punjab, Pakistan. Pak. Sci. Int., 28: 295-298.

Ayisi, C.L., Zhao, J., and Rupia, E.J., 2017. Growth performance, feed utilization, body and fatty acid composition of Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) fed diets containing elevated levels of palm oil. Aquacult. Fish., 2: 67-77. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aaf.2017.02.001

Ayisi, C. L., Zhao, J., Yame, C., Apraku, A., and Debra, G., 2019. Effects of replacing fish oil with palm oil in diets of Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) on muscle biochemical composition, enzyme activities, and mRNA expression of growth-related genes. Fish. aquat. Sci., 22: 1-9. https://doi.org/10.1186/s41240-019-0139-y

Cottrell, R.S., Blanchard, J.L., Halpern, B.S., Metian, M., and Froehlich, H.E., 2020. Global adoption of novel aquaculture feeds could substantially reduce forage fish demand by 2030. Nat. Fd., 1: 301-308. https://doi.org/10.1038/s43016-020-0078-x

Dawood, M.A., 2021. Nutritional immunity of fish intestines: Important insights for sustainable aquaculture. Rev. Aquacult., 13: 642-663. https://doi.org/10.1111/raq.12492

Dernekbasi, S., Akyüz, A.P., and Karayücel, İ., 2021. Effects of total replacement of dietary fish oil by vegetable oils on growth performance, nutritional quality and fatty acid profiles of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) at optimum-and high temperature conditions. Ege J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 38: 237-246. https://doi.org/10.12714/egejfas.38.2.14

Diana, J.S., Egna, H.S., Chopin, T., Peterson, M.S., Cao, L., Pomeroy, R., and Cabello, F., 2013. Responsible aquaculture in 2050: valuing local conditions and human innovations will be key to success. BioScience, 63: 255-262. https://doi.org/10.1525/bio.2013.63.4.5

Divakaran, S., Obaldo, L.G., and Forster, I.P., 2002. Note on the methods for determination of chromic oxide in shrimp feeds. J. agric. Fd. Chem., 50: 464-467. https://doi.org/10.1021/jf011112s

Duan, Q., Mai, K., Shentu, J., Ai, Q., Zhong, H., Jiang, Y., and Guo, S., 2014. Replacement of dietary fish oil with vegetable oils improves the growth and flesh quality of large yellow croaker (Larmichthys crocea). J. Ocean Univ. China, 13: 445-452. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11802-014-2188-2

El-Asely, A.M., Reda, R.M., Salah, A.S., Mahmoud, M.A., and Dawood, M.A., 2020. Overall performances of Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) associated with using vegetable oil sources under suboptimal temperature. Aquacult. Nutr., 26: 1154-1163. https://doi.org/10.1111/anu.13072

Erondu, E.S., Akpoilih, B.U., and John, F.S., 2021. Total replacement of dietary fish oil with vegetable lipid sources influenced growth performance, whole body composition, and protein retention in Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) fingerlings. J. appl. Aquacult., 49: 1-20. https://doi.org/10.1080/10454438.2021.1960230

Food and Agriculture Organization, 2020. Sustainability in action. State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture. Rome, pp. 200.

Fukada, H., Taniguchi, E., Morioka, K., and Masumoto, T., 2017. Effects of replacing fish oil with canola oil on the growth performance, fatty acid composition and metabolic enzyme activity of juvenile yellowtail Seriola quinqueradiata (Temminck and Schlegel, 1845). Aquacult. Res., 48: 5928-5939. https://doi.org/10.1111/are.13416

Gasco, L., Gai, F., Maricchiolo, G., Genovese, L., Ragonese, S., Bottari, T., and Caruso, G., 2018. Fishmeal alternative protein sources for aquaculture feeds. In: Feeds for the aquaculture sector. Springer, Cham. pp. 1-28. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-77941-6_1

Kok, B., Malcorps, W., Tlusty, M.F., Eltholth, M.M., Auchterlonie, N.A., Little, D.C., and Davies, S.J., 2020. Fish as feed: Using economic allocation to quantify the fish. In: Fish out ratio of major fed aquaculture species. Aquaculture, 528: 735474. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2020.735474

Larbi-Ayisi, C., Zhao, J., and Wu, J.W., 2018. Replacement of fish oil with palm oil: Effects on growth performance, innate immune response, antioxidant capacity and disease resistance in Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus). PLoS One, 13: e0196100. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0196100

Lovell, T., 1989. Nutrition and feeding of fish (Vol. 260). Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4757-1174-5

Milián-Sorribes, M.C., Martínez-Llorens, S., Cruz-Castellón, C., Jover-Cerdá, M., and Tomás-Vidal, A., 2021. Effect of fish oil replacement and probiotic addition on growth, body composition and histological parameters of yellowtail (Seriola dumerili). Aquacult. Nutr., 27: 3-16. https://doi.org/10.1111/anu.13171

Milstein, A., Wahab, M.A., and Rahman, M.M., 2002. Environmental effects of common carp Cyprinus carpio (L.) and mrigal Cirrhinus mrigala (Hamilton) as bottom feeders in major Indian carp polycultures. Aquacult. Res., 33: 1103-1117. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2109.2002.00753.x

Mu, H., Wei, C., Xu, W., Gao, W., Zhang, W., and Mai, K., 2020. Effects of replacement of dietary fish oil by rapeseed oil on growth performance, anti-oxidative capacity and inflammatory response in large yellow croaker Larimichthys crocea. Aquacult. Rep., 16: 100251. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aqrep.2019.100251

NRC, 1993. Nutrient requirements of fish.

Peng, X., Li, F., Lin, S., and Chen, Y., 2016. Effects of total replacement of fish oil on growth performance, lipid metabolism and antioxidant capacity in tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus). Aquacult. Int., 24: 145-156. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10499-015-9914-7

Rowland, S.J., and Ingram, B.A., 1991. Diseases of Australian native fishes. In: Fisheries bulletin. 4 NSW Fisheries, Sydney, NSW, Australia.

Sankian, Z., Khosravi, S., Kim, Y.O., and Lee, S.M., 2019. Total replacement of dietary fish oil with alternative lipid sources in a practical diet for mandarin fish, Siniperca scherzeri, juveniles. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 22: 1-9. https://doi.org/10.1186/s41240-019-0123-6

Shahrooz, R., Agh, N., Jafari, N., Kalantari, A., Jalili, R., and Karimi, A., 2018. Effects of fish oil replacement with vegetable oils in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) fingerlings diet on growth performance and foregut histology. Turk. J. Fish. aquat. Sci., 18: 825-832. https://doi.org/10.4194/1303-2712-v18_6_09

Shahzad, M.M., Hussain, S.M., Javid, A., and Hussain, M., 2018. Role of phytase supplementation in improving growth parameters and mineral digestibility of Catla catla fingerlings fed moringa by-products based test diet. Turk. J. Fish. aquat. Sci., 18: 557-566.

Snedecor, G.W., and Cochran, W.G., 1991. Statistical methods. 8th Ed. Iowa State University Press, Americans. USA, pp. 503.

Steel, R. and Torrie, J., 1996. Principles and procedures of statistics. McGraw-Hill Book Co, London.

Turchini, G.M., Torstensen, B.E., and Ng, W.K., 2009. Fish oil replacement in finfish nutrition. Rev. Aquacult., 1: 10-57. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1753-5131.2008.01001.x

Turchini, G.M., Trushenski, J.T., and Glencross, B.D., 2019. Thoughts for the future of aquaculture nutrition: Realigning perspectives to reflect contemporary issues related to judicious use of marine resources in aquafeeds. N. Am. J. Aquacult., 81: 13-39. https://doi.org/10.1002/naaq.10067

Vanitha, M., Dhanapal, K., and Vidya Sagar Reddy, G., 2015. Quality changes in fish burger from Catla (Catla catla) during refrigerated storage. J. Fd. Sci. Technol., 52: 1766-1771. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13197-013-1161-1

Wabike, E.E., Wu, X., Zhu, W., Lou, B., Chen, R., Xu, D., and Tan, P., 2020. Partial replacement of fish oil with terrestrial lipid blend and effects on growth performance, body composition, immune parameter and growth-related genes in yellow drum (Nibea albiflora). Aquacult. Nutr., 26: 954-963. https://doi.org/10.1111/anu.13053