Effect of Different Dietary Oils on Growth, Feed Conversion and Body Composition of Juvenile Black Fin Sea Bream, Acanthopagrus berda (Forsskal, 1775)

Abdur Rahim1, Ghulam Abbas1,*, Muhammad Naeem2, Sara Ferrando3, Lorenzo Gallus3, Muhammad Hafeez-ur-Rehman4, Abdul Ghaffar5 and Abdul Mateen6

1Centre of Excellence in Marine Biology, University of Karachi, Karachi-75270, Pakistan

2Institute of Pure and Applied Biology, Zoology Division, Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan. 60800.

3Department of Earth, Environment and Life Sciences (DISTAV), University of Genoa, Italy

4Department of Fisheries and Aquaculture, University of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, Lahore, Pakistan

5Department of Life Sciences, The Islamia University of Bahawalpur, Bahawalpur, Pakistan

6Department of Zoology, Wildlife and Fisheries, University of Agriculture, Faisalabad, Pakistan

ABSTRACT

In this study, effect of varying dietary oils on growth, nutrient utilization and body composition of juvenile black fin sea bream Acanthopagrus berda was investigated. Fish juvenile (10.1±0.5 g) were collected from Sonari Channel, Hawksbay, Karachi and were brought to aquaculture laboratory of the Centre for 15 days acclimatization. After acclimatization, they were randomly distributed into the rectangular tanks (3 × 1.5 ×1.5 ft each). In each tank, 10 fish were stocked with three replications for each treatment. Four isonitrogenous diets containing different oils i.e., fish oil (FO), soybean oil (SO), olive oil (OO) and palm oil (PO) were given to the juveniles for 60 days. Best specific growth rate (SGR) and feed conversion ratio (FCR) were noted in the fish fed diet containing FO. Fish fed diet comprising OO and PO showed poor SGR and FCR values than those fed with FO and SO diets. Body composition was not significantly influenced by different lipid sources although low crude lipid was found in fish fed diet containing FO. The hepatosomatic index (HSI) and visrosomatic index (VSI) were greater in the fish fed FO diet than the remaining diets. Finally, it was concluded that fish oil is the best source of energy in fish diet followed by soybean oil for A. berda growing from 10.1 g and 69.2 g. Further study is required for optimization of fish oil level and replacement of FO with vegetative oils.

Article Information

Received 02 September 2015

Revised 21 December 2015

Accepted 30 April 2016

Available online 2 April 2017

Authors’ Contributions

GA conceived and designed the project and wrote the article. AR performed the experimental work. MHR analyzed feed component. AM analyzed fish meat samples. MN and AG statistically analyzed the data. SF and LG helped in preparation of manuscript.

Key words

Sea bream (Acanthopagrus berda), Growth, Feed conversion, Body composition, Dietary oils.

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17582/journal.pjz/2017.49.2.655.661

* Corresponding author: [email protected]

0030-9923/2017/0002-0655 $ 9.00/0

Copyright 2017 Zoological Society of Pakistan

INTRODUCTION

 

Sea breams are considered as important candidate for aquaculture in the world (Sa et al., 2006; Abbas et al., 2015). In Pakistan, it has commercial value due to good quality meat (Anonymous, 2012). In order to develop sustainable aquaculture of sea bream, its nutrient requirements must be known. Fish feed is considered as the most important component for such intensive aquaculture and one of the costly components of this feed is oil (Rosenlund et al., 2001; Abbas et al., 2011, 2015). The dietary oil contains lipids which are used as source of energy (Dong et al., 2014). In addition, lipids have high poly unsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) which contribute well to cell membrane and other organelles (Rosenlund et al., 2001; Mateen et al., 2016). In marine carnivorous fishes, need of lipid is very impotent because of having little ability to consume carbohydrate (Mourente and Bell, 2006). It is well known that marine finfishes require dietary PUFAs for growth, thus their inclusion must be balanced for maximum progression. In this regard, main oil source is fish oil which can be produced by small pelagic fishes (FAO, 2012). But due to over exploitation of fisheries resources, the landing of fish for oil production is declining. To overcome this alarming situation, alternatives to fish oil for inclusion in diet is necessary (Turchinia et al., 2003). In response of high production and low cost of vegetable oils such as soybean oil, palm oil, rapeseed oil, olive oil, and corn oil have been investigated to include in diets of salmon, trout, European sea bass and gilthead sea bream (Regost et al., 2003; Mourente et al., 2005; Mourente and Bell, 2006). According to these studies, replacement fish oil with vegetable oil is important for enhancing fish growth. Since, Pakistan is an agricultural country, having greater production of soybean oil (467-1314kg/hector/ annum), olive oil (500-1000 kg/ hector/ annum) and palm oil (1000 MT /year), these oils can be used as alternate source of fish oil. But, it was observed that vegetable oils have less number of fatty acid and trypsin inhibitors indigestible carbohydrate so can’t replace totally (Aberoumand, 2012). Therefore, a study was undertaken to investigate best oil source with optimum concentration for black fin sea bream A. berda. The objective of this study was to determine the effects of fish oil, soybean oil, olive oil and palm oil on growth, nutrient utilization, and body composition of juvenile black fin sea bream A. berda in captivity.

 

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Experimental diet

Four isonitrogenous (42% protein) diets were prepared from locally available ingredients on dry matter basis (g/100 g) (Table I). Four different oils i.e., fish oil (FO), soybean oil (SO), olive oil (OO) and palm oil (PO) were used as source of energy in each experimental diet (Table I). Fish meal was added as major source of protein and wheat flour was used as source of carbohydrate. Mixture of minerals and vitamins were also included in the diets. All the ingredients were weighed, grounded and mixed mechanically to realize homogeneity of ingredients. Water (150ml / kg) was added to the mixture and was remixed. Thus soft dough was prepared which was pelleted by using 2mm die. Subsequently, these pellets were dried under shade for 10 h. The experimental diets were then stored at -4°C for further use.

Experimental procedure and feeding trial

Black fin sea bream juveniles, A. berda (mean initial body weight 10.1±0.5 g) were collected from Sonari channel, Hawksbay, Karachi. They were acclimatized for 15 days before starting the trial. After acclimatization, they were randomly distributed into the experimental rectangular tanks (3.0 × 1.5 ×1.5 ft each). In each tank, 10 fish were stocked with three replications for each treatment. All the tanks were supplied with sand-filtered seawater continuously. All fishes were placed in similar light with photoperiod of 12L:12D. Fish were fed three times a day (09:00, 13:00 and 17:00) up to 60 days on the ration of 2% wet body weight. Feed was supplied by hand and feed intake was estimated. Each tank was cleaned daily by siphoning. After each 10 days fish body weight and length were noted carefully.

 

Table I.- Ingredients of experimental diets containing fish oil (FO), soybean oil (SO), olive oil (OO) and palm oil (PO).

Ingredients (g /100g)	Experimental diets
	FO	SO	OO	PO
Fish meal	37.5	37.5	37.5	37.5
MAB1	7.5	7.5	7.5	7.5
Cod liver oil	10	0	0	0
Soybean oil	0	10	0	0
Olive oil	0	0	10	0
Palm oil	0	0	0	10
Corn gluten meal	12.5	12.5	12.5	12.5
Lupine seed meal	4.5	4.5	4.5	4.5
Wheat flour	14	14	14	14
Tapioca flour	6.0	6.0	6.0	6.0
Yeast	6.0	6.0	6.0	6.0
Vitamin-mineral premix2	2.0	2.0	2.0	2.0

1A mixture of animal by-products (MAB) consisted of 25% cow liver meal, 20% meat and bone meal, 15% blood meal, 10% APC (poultry feather meal), 8% poultry manure dried, 2% choline.

2Vitamin and mineral mixture contained the following ingredients (g/100 g diet): Ascorbic acid (vit C), 15.3; thiamin HCl (vit B6), 1.0; inositol, 39.5; calcium, 1.25; zinc, 1.0; retinol (vit A), 1.0; phosphorus, 3.5; choline chloride, 3.5; magnesium, 2.5; copper, 1.0; pyridoxine (vit B6), 1.3; phospholipids, 3.5; α-tocopherol acetate (vit E), 5.5; folic acid, 0.4; cholecalciferol (vit D3), 7.5; cyanocobalamine (vit B12), 0.006; riboflavin (vit B2), 1.5; menadione sodium bisulphite (vit K3), 0.03; manganese, 2.0; iodine, 2.0; sodium, 1.0; iron, 1.0; nicotinic acid, 4.3; biotin, 0.35.

 

Chemical analysis and measurement

At the end of the experiment, three fishes from each tank were killed and were dissected to calculate the weight of liver and viscera so as to determine their hepatosomatic index (HSI) and visrosomatic index (VSI). The remaining fishes were used for whole body composition analysis. Moisture, crude lipid and crude protein contents were determined by using the standard procedures of AOAC (2000). Moisture was determined with the help of an oven (Labostar-LG122 Tabia Espec, Osaka, Japan), crude lipid was estimated by chloroform / methanol (2:1v/v) extraction procedure (Folch et al., 1957). Crude protein was determined by Kjeldahl method (N×6.25) through automatic Kjeldahl system (Buchi 430/323). Ash was calculated by burning in a furnace (Isuzu Seisajusho, Tokyo, Japan). Energy was determined with the help of an automatic bomb-calorimeter (Parr Instruments, model 1265, Moline IL, USA).

Calculations and statistical analysis

The percent weight gain (WG %), condition factor (CF), feed intake (FI), specific growth rate (SGR), feed conversion ratio (FCR), hapatosomatic index (HSI), protein efficiency ratio (PER) and (VSI) visrosomatic index were determined by the following formulae:

 

WG = % of initial weight =100 × final weight–initial

weight / initial weight.

CF = 100 × weight / length3

FI = diet given as % body weight – remaining diet pellets.

SGR = 100 × (ln final weight – in initial weight/ period).

FCR = diet given / weight gain.

HIS = wet of liver (g) / empty fish weight (g) ×100: total of

initial was 1.24%.

PER = wet weight gain / protein (N×6.25) intake.

VSI = 100 × wet weight of visceral organs and associated

fat tissue (g) / wet body weight g.

 

The experimental data was evaluated through one way analysis of variance (ANOVA) to determine growth performance and product quality. Difference among means was calculated by 5% probability level addressing Duncan’s multiple range test (Zar, 1996).

 

RESULTS

Water quality

Water temperature was consistent at 26.5±0.5oC. Dissolved oxygen concentration remained up to 7.0±0.2 ml/l and pH was generally alkaline with slight variation among the tanks; pH values were around 6.5±0.2 throughout the study period. Ammonia and nitrites were not more than 0.01±0.001 ml/l. Salinity was usually between 18-20 %.

Chemical composition of diets

Four experimental diets containing different oils such as FO, SO, OO and PO were chemically analyzed. The composition reveals that each diet has lipid 10.9–11%, protein 42.1–42.3%, moister 6.5–8.3%, ash 12.8–13.8%, fiber 3.3–3.4 %, calcium 2.2–2.5%, NFE 27.6–29.5% and energy 3875.2–3889.2 kJ/100g (Table II).

Growth, feed efficiency and condition indices

No adverse effects were found on health and no mortality was observed during the entire study period. The specific growth rate (SGR) of fish fed diet containing FO showed highest value following the same of fish fed SO, OO and PO (Table III). However, SGR of the reaming three diets were not significantly different (P>0.05; Table III). Higher weight gain (585.14%) was noted in fish fed with FO in contrast with SO, OO and PO diets (Table III; Fig. 1). Lower FCR (0.046) was observed in fish fed diet containing FO (Table III). Feed intake was not significantly affected by the dietary oil inclusion in the trail. The PER value (1.47) of fish fed FO diets was considerably higher, although the PER of the OO and PO diets were same and SO diet has intermediate value (Table III). Higher hepatosomatic index (HSI) was observed in fish fed with FO and lower HSI were noted in fish fed with diets containing OO and PO (Table III). Lower VSI was noted in the fish fed with olive oil and higher VSI was observed in fish fed fish oil diets. However, VSI of fish fed with SO and PO were intermediate (Table III). No significant difference was noted in the values of conditions factor (2.7%) among all treatments.

 

Table II.- Chemical analysis (% DM) of the experimental diets containing fish oil (FO), soybean oil (SO), olive oil (OO) and palm oil (PO).

Constituents1	Experimental diets
	FO	SO	OO	PO
Moisture	8.3±0.11	6.5±0.14	7.1±0.30	7.1±0.33
Protein2	42.1±1.20	42.2±1.11	42.3±1.22	42.3±1.21
Lipid	11.2±0.12	12.1±0.13	12.3±0.27	12.3±0.26
Ash	12.8±0.23	13.1±0.10	13.5±0.20	13.5±0.16
Fiber	4.4±0.31	4.3±0.11	4.3±0.24	4.3±0.20
NFE3	29.5±1.21	28.3±0.19	27.6±0.21	27.6±0.18
Calcium	2.5±0.11	2.2±0.13	2.3±0.23	2.5±0.24
Phosphorus	1.6±0.10	1.4±0.21	1.6±0.26	1.6±0.10
Gross energy (kJ/100g)	3876.2± 2.31	3889.2± 2.21	3880.1± 2.44	3880.5± 2.11

1Dry matter basis (%); mean ± SE, number of determination = 5.

2Measured as nitrogen × 6.25.

3Nitrogen-free extract = 100 – [(% protein + % fat + % ash + % fiber)].

Similar superscripts indicate no statistical difference among treatments; initial fish weight is 10.1±0.5 g.

 

Body composition

Crude lipid was higher in fish fed diets containing PO and OO but lower in the fish given FO diets. Moreover, crude lipid of fish fed with SO was intermediate (Table IV). No significant difference was observed in crude protein of fish with different oil as energy source. Moister content of fish fed with SO was significantly higher than FO, OO and PO (Table IV). Crude fiber of fish fed with fish oil (FO) was slightly greater than SO, OO and PO. Ash content was not significantly affected by the oil source. No differences in the gross energy contents were observed among all treatments (Table IV).

 

Table III.- Growth performance of black fin sea bream, A. berda fed diets containing fish oil (FO), soybean oil (SO), olive oil (OO) and palm oil (PO).

Parameters	Experimental diets
	FO	SO	OO	PO
Final weight (g)	69.21± 1.21a	65.41± 1.37a	65.11± 1.25a	65.21± 1.24a
WG1	585.14± 2.31b	547.52± 2.21a	444.55± 2.26a	445.54± 2.20a
SGR2	3.21± 0.11b	2.83± 0.13a	2.82± 0.21a	2.82±0. 14a
Feed intake3	27.30± 1.21a	31.11± 1.20b	32.20± 1.30b	32.40± 1.25b
FCR4	0.046± 0.001a	0.056± 0.001b	0.072± 0.002b	0.072± 0.001b
PER5	1.47± 0.11b	1.38± 0.10a	1.36± 0.12a	1.36± 0.20a
HSI6	2.11± 0.01b	1.61± 0.01a	1.21± 0.02a	1.40± 0.01a
VSI7	3.31± 0.01b	2.51± 0.02a	2.11± 0.01a	2.51± 0.02a
CF8	2.78± 0.21a	2.74± 0.20a	2.74± 0.19a	2.75± 0.18a
Survival %	100	100	100	100

1Weight gain, % of initial weight =100 × final weight – initial weight / initial weight. 2SGR =100 × (ln final weight – ln initial weight / period). 3FI = diet given as % body weight – remaining diet pellets.

4FCR = diet given / weight gain). 5PER = wet weight gain / N×6.25 intake. 6HSI = wet of liver (g) / empty fish weight (g) ×100: total of initial was 1.24%. 7VSI = 100 × [wet weight of visceral organs and associated fat tissue (g) / wet body weight g]. 8CF =100 × weight / length3.

 

 

Table IV.- Whole body composition of A. berda fed diets containing fish oil (FO), soybean oil (SO), olive oil (OO) and palm oil (PO).

Constituents1	Experimental diets
	FO	SO	OO	PO
Crud lipid (%)	6.72± 0.12a	6.51± 0.11a	6.81± 0.09a	6.90± 0.11a
Crud protein1 (%)	16.81± 1.11a	16.40± 1.21a	16.10± 1.20a	16.21± 1.13a
Moister (%)	73.50± 1.21a	73.81± 1.41a	73.11± 1.21a	73.32± 1.30a
Crude fiber (%)	1.54± 0.10a	1.42± 0.11a	1.31± 0.10a	1.30± 0.09a
Ash (%)	3.12± 0.10a	3.51± 0.21a	3.73± 0.23a	3.42± 0.20a
Gross energy kJ/g (%)	32.52± 1.20a	32.90± 1.21a	32.61± 1.31a	32.52± 1.26a

Similar superscripts indicate no statistical difference among treatments. Chemical composition of stocking fish: moisture = 71 %, protein = 52.3 %, lipid = 34.1 %, ash = 11.3 %. 1Measured as nitrogen ×6.25.

 

DISCUSSION

 

In the present study, juvenile black fin sea bream, A. berda were shown to have higher WG and SGR at diets encompassing FO as energy source. This higher growth might have been due to the fact that FO has good profile of fatty acids that enhanced growth performance of the fish. Evidence to support this is available from the finding of El-Husseiny et al. (2013) and Bahurmiz and Ng (2007). In addition, Peng et al. (2008) and Francis et al. (2006) studied the effects of replacing dietary fish oil with soybean oil for black sea bream (Acanthopagrus schlegeli) and achieved higher growth with fish oil diets. Similar observations were reported by Bahurmiz and Ng (2007). In the present study, WG and SGR of the fish fed diets containing soybean oil, olive oil and palm oil were slightly less than those of the fish fed with fish oil. It may be due to the shortage of arachidonic acid which is only found in fish and other sea animals. Similar conclusions were found by Peng et al. (2008) and Bahurmiz and Ng, 2007). These authors stated that complete substitution of fish oil with soybean oil reduced growth efficiency parallel with the findings of our study. In the present study, FCR and PER were affected by the dietary oils source. The high FCR and PER of the fish fed diet including FO indicated that diets with fish oil as energy source are helpful to protein conversion than SO, OO and PO, agreeing with the results of Regost et al. (2003) while working on the effect of different oils as source of energy in fish diet. According to them, fish oil enhances growth as well as fatty acid profile of the fish. Since FO is considered as costly component of fish diet, its alternatives like vegetable oil (soybean oil, olive oil, palm oil etc.) should be incorporated in diets as energy source (Rahim et al., 2015).

In this study, soybean oil was found to be the second best source of energy in the diets similar to the finding of Figueiredo-Silva et al. (2005), Cabral et al. (2013), Regost et al. (2003) and Mourente et al. (2005). But, FCR value of the fish fed soybean oil based diet was somewhat less than that of the fish fed diet having FO. This indicates that total replacement of fish oil with soybean oil slightly decreases the growth but this issue could be resolved by determining the level of replacing fish oil with soybean oil. The limit of replacement depends on the need of fatty acid for species used in culture system, agreeing with Mourente et al. (2005) and Regost et al. (2003). No significant difference in WG and FCR were observed in the fish fed with PO and OO based diet as energy source. Similar results were reported by Ng et al. (2000) while studying on catfish. He revealed that palm oil can successfully be used in feed of catfish to enhance the growth. In addition, Bahurmiz and Ng (2007) confirmed that palm oil can be totally substituted in tilapia diet instead of fish oil throughout their growth period without affecting growth until harvesting with little deficit in fatty acid profile. Number of studies (Lim et al., 2001; Mourente and Bell, 2006; Bahurmiz and Ng, 2007) showed that palm oil are feasible alternative in fish diet as described in the present study. Since dietary fatty acid profile play significant role for enhancing meat quality of fish and fatty acid profile with regard to human health as well. Therefore, further studies are required for the assessment of fatty acid composition in case of palm oil as source of lipid. Olive oil in the present trail also gives moderate performance regarding growth similar to the finding of Mourente et al. (2005). According to him, olive oil can potentially be used in diet of European sea bass without compromising its growth. This performance can be improve by adding fish oil in diet even in little amount. Positive correlation between hapatosomatic index and growth rate was observed in the present study which is parallel to the results of Bransdena et al. (2003).

In case of whole body composition, crude protein was not significantly influenced by the dietary oils. This indicates that lipid source has no effect on body protein due to protein sparing effects (Bransdena et al., 2003; Bendiksen et al., 2003; Ovie et al., 2005; Li et al., 2012). Inverse relation between moister and crude lipid was found in the present study agreeing with the findings of Abbas et al. (2015) and Rahim et al. (2015) who noted negative correlation of fats with moister content. In the present study, ash was not influenced by the dietary lipid sources. These results were advocated by Mourente et al. (2005). He concluded that dietary lipid sources have no effect on ash content of the fish. Gross energy was noted same among all treatments in this study.

Finally, it was concluded that the best source of energy for maximum growth of sea bream A. berda was fish oil and second best oil source to enhance the growth was soybean oil. After that, palm oil and olive oil can be used in fish diet successfully. But, further study is required to optimize fish oil in diets of sea bream in captivity.

 

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

 

The senior author is grateful to the HEC for providing facilities and fellowship to complete this work as a part of Ph.D. research.

 

Statement of conflict of interest

Authors have declared no conflict of interest.

 

REFERENCES

 

Abbas, G., Siddiqui, P.J.A. and Jamil, K., 2011. The optimal protein requirements of juvenile mangrove red snapper, Lutjanus argentimaculatus fed isoenergetic diet. Pakistan J. Zool., 44: 469-480.

Abbas, G., Waryani, B., Ghaffar, A., Rahim, A., Hafeez-ur-Rehman, M. and Aslam, M., 2015. Effect of ration size and feeding frequency on growth, feed utilization, body composition and some haematological characteristics of juvenile snapper, Lutjanus johnii (Baloch, 1792). Pakistan J. Zool., 47: 719–730.

Aberoumand, A., 2012. A research work on chemical composition and quality of some fishes meals in Iran. World J. Fish. Mar. Sci., 2: 505–507.

AOAC, 2000. Official methods of analysis of association of official analytical chemists Vol. I. 17th edn. Association of Official Analytical Chemists, Arlington, USA, pp. 684.

Anonymous, 2012. Hand book of fisheries statistics of Pakistan. A publication of Marine Fisheries Department, Government of Pakistan, Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Cooperatives (Livestock Division), 20: pp. 215.

Bahurmiz, O.M. and Ng, W.K., 2007. Effects of dietary palm oil source on growth, tissue fatty acid composition and nutrient digestibility of red hybrid tilapia, Oreochromis sp., raised from stocking to marketable size. Aquaculture, 262: 382–392. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2006.11.023

Bransdena, M.P., Carterb, C.G. and Nicholsc, P.D., 2003. Replacement of fish oil with sunflower oil in feeds for Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.): effect on growth performance, tissue fatty acid composition and disease resistance. Comp. Biochem. Physiol., 135: 611–625. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1096-4959(03)00143-X

Bendiksen, E.A., Berg, O.K., Jobling, M., Arnesen, A.M. and Masoval, K., 2003. Digestibility, growth and nutrient utilization of Atlantic salmon parr (Salmo salar L.) in relation to temperature, feed fat content and oil source. Aquaculture, 224: 283–299. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0044-8486(03)00218-7

Cabral, M., Fernandes, T.J.R., Campos, S.D., Castro-Cunha, M., Oliveira, M.B.P.P. and Cunha-valente, L.M.P., 2013. Replacement of fish meal by plant protein sources up to 75% induces good growth performance without affecting flesh quality of growing Senegalese sole. Aquaculture, 380: 130–138. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2012.12.006

Dong, G., Zhu, X., Ren, H., Nie, B., Chen, L., Li, H. and Yan, B., 2014. Effects of oxidized fish oil intake on tissue lipid metabolism and fatty acid composition of channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus). Aquacult. Res., 45: 1867–1880.

El-Husseiny, O.M., Elhammady, A.K.I., Tolba, S.M. and Suloma, A., 2013. Llipid and protein utilization by Gilthead sea bream (Sparus aurata L.) under flow-through system with regard to environmental impact. J. Arabian Aquacult. Soc., 8: 307–320.

FAO, 2012. The state of world fisheries and aquaculture. Pp. 1–29.

Folch, A.C., Leed, M. and Sloane-Stanley, G.M., 1957. A simple method for isolation and purification of total lipids from animal tissues. J. biol. Chem., 226: 497–509.

Francis, D.S., Turchini, G.M., Jones, O.L. and De-Silvas, C., 2006. Effects of dietary oil source on growth and fillet fatty acid composition of Murray cod, Maccullochella peelii. Aquaculture, 253: 547–556. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2005.08.008

Figueiredo-Silva1, A., Rocha1, E., Dias, J., Silva1, P., Rema, P., Gomes, E. and Valente, L.M.P., 2005. Partial replacement of fish oil by soybean oil on lipid distribution and liver histology in European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax) and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) juvenile. Aquacult. Nutr., 11: 147–155.

Li, X., Jiang, Y., Liu, W. and Ge, X., 2012. Protein-sparing effect of dietary lipid in practical diets for blunt snout bream (Megalobrama amblycephala) fingerlings: effects on digestive and metabolic responses. Fish Physiol. Biochem., 38: 529–541. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10695-011-9533-9

Lim, P.K., Boey, P.L. and Ng, W.K., 2001. Dietary palm oil level affects growth performance, protein retention and tissue vitamin E concentration of African catfish, Clarias gariepinus. Aquaculture, 202: 101–112. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0044-8486(01)00563-4

Mateen, A., Ghaffar, A., Abbas, G., Ferrando, S. and Gallus, L., 2016. Body composition and fatty acid profile of carps under the influence of rice polish and pond fertilization. Pakistan J. Zool., 48: 1263-1267.

Mourente, G. and Bell, J.G., 2006. Partial replacement of dietary fish oil with blends of vegetable oils (rapeseed, linseed and palm oils) in diets for European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax L.) over a long term growth study: Effects on muscle and liver fatty acid composition and effectiveness of a fish oil finishing diet. Comp. Biochem. Physiol., Part B 145: 389–399. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cbpb.2006.08.012

Ng, W.K., Lu, K.S., Hashim, R. and Ali, A., 2000. Effects of feeding rate on growth, feed utilization and body composition of a tropical bagrid catfish. Aquacult. Int., 8: 19-29. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009216831360

Peng, S., Chen, L., Qin, J.Q., Hou, J., Yua, N., Long, Z., Ye, J. and Sun, X., 2008. Effects of replacement of dietary fish oil by soybean oil on growth performance and liver biochemical composition in juvenile black sea bream, Acanthopagrus schlegeli. Aquaculture, 276: 154–161. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2008.01.035

Mourente, G., Good, J.E. and Bell, J.G., 2005. Partial substitution of fish oil with rapeseed, linseed and olive oils in diets for European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax L.): effects on flesh fatty acid composition, plasma prostaglandins E2 and F2a, immune function and effectiveness of a fish oil finishing diet. Aquacult. Nutr., 11: 25–40. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2095.2004.00320.x

Ovie, S.O., Sadiku, S.O.E. and Ovie, S., 2005. Protein sparing activity of lipid and carbohydrate in the Giant African mudfish, H. longifilis diets. J. Appl. Sci. Environ Mamage., 9: 109–113.

Rahim, A., Abbas, G., Waryani, B., Ghaffar, A., Monwar, M.M., Hafeez-ur-Rehman, M. and Dastagir, G., 2015. Influence of varying dietary lipid levels on growth, feed conversion and chemical composition of meat and liver of the juvenile blackfin sea bream, Acanthopagrus berda (Forsskal, 1775). Pakistan J. Zool., 47: 1467–1473.

Rosenlund, G., Obach, A., Sandberg, G.M., Standal, H. and Tveit, K., 2001. Effect of alternative lipid sources on long-term growth performance and quality of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.). Aquacult. Res., 32: 323–328. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1355-557x.2001.00025.x

Regost, C., Arzel, J., Rosenlund, R.G. and Kaushik, S.J., 2003. Total replacement of fish oil by soybean or linseed oil with a return to fish oil in turbot (Psetta maxima). Growth performance, flesh fatty acid profile, and lipid metabolism. Aquaculture, 217: 465–482. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0044-8486(02)00259-4

Sa, R., Pousao-Ferreira, P. and Oliva-teles, A., 2006. Effect of dietary protein and lipid levels on growth and feed utilization of white sea bream (Diplodus sargus) juveniles. Aquacult. Nutr., 12: 310–321. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2095.2006.00434.x

Turchinia, G.M., Mentastia, T., Froylandb, L., Orbanc, E., Caprinoa, F., Morettia, V.M. and Valfre, F., 2003. Effects of alternative dietary lipid sources on performance, tissue chemical composition, mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation capabilities and sensory characteristics in brown trout (Salmo trutta L.). Aquaculture, 225: 251–267. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0044-8486(03)00294-1

Zar, J.H., 1996. Biostatistical analysis. Prentice-Hall Inc., New Jersey, pp. 662.